Judge Denies Bid To Dismiss Clancy's Case, Sets March Retrial
A Plymouth Superior Court judge has told Lindsay Clancy she's getting a second trial. He denied her bid to dismiss the triple-murder case and set March 29, 2027, as the new trial date, ruling that one holdout juror's September mistrial doesn't bar prosecutors from trying again.
Case at a glance
- Lindsay Clancy — subject
Next: Clancy goes back to trial March 29, 2027, in Plymouth Superior Court, still facing three counts of first-degree murder, with Judge William Sullivan on the bench again. Prosecutors haven't said whether they'll change their approach this time. The defense is expected to make the same argument it made the first time: that postpartum psychosis left Clancy without criminal responsibility for the killings.

Three children dead, one juror held out
Cora was 5. Dawson was 3. Callan was 8 months old. On Jan. 24, 2023, their mother, Lindsay Clancy, strangled all three in the basement of the family's home in Duxbury, Massachusetts. Patrick Clancy, her then-husband, was out running errands — a stop at CVS, then a takeout order — when it happened.
Clancy's lawyers never argued she didn't do it. Their case all along has been that she shouldn't be held criminally responsible, because she was in the grip of severe postpartum psychosis. She pleaded not guilty to three counts of first-degree murder — one for each child.
The trial ran five weeks in Plymouth Superior Court. Patrick Clancy took the stand, along with dozens of Clancy's mental-health providers. A jury of nine women and three men deliberated for seven days before telling Judge William Sullivan they were deadlocked. Eleven of them were reportedly ready to find Clancy not guilty by reason of lack of criminal responsibility. One juror held out.
Sullivan declared a mistrial on Sept. 4, 2026. Clancy's lawyers came back swinging: a motion to dismiss the case on double jeopardy grounds, a motion for a required finding of not guilty, and a push to dig into the holdout juror's conduct and records.
Monday, Nov. 9, 2026: Sullivan denied the motion to dismiss. He turned down the defense's request for the juror's records too, and denied a prosecution request for a gag order. That same hearing, prosecutors said for the first time that they plan to retry Clancy. The parties were back in court a week later, on Nov. 16, when Sullivan set the new trial date: March 29, 2027.
The family, the judge, the holdout
Lindsay Clancy is 36 years old and faces three counts of first-degree murder. She's been held at Tewksbury State Hospital, a psychiatric facility, since 2023. In court, she uses a wheelchair — the lasting mark of suicide attempts that left her with serious injuries.
Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months, were Clancy's children, and they're the victims in this case. Patrick Clancy, her then-husband, was out of the house when the killings happened. He testified that Clancy had called a suicide hotline twice and had been released from a psychiatric hospital just weeks before. He and Clancy have since filed separate civil lawsuits against her mental-health providers.
Judge William Sullivan is presiding over the case and is expected to run the retrial too. Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague is prosecuting; Kevin Reddington represents Clancy. The holdout juror from the first trial has been publicly identified as Michael Péguy Desronvil, who says other jurors misrepresented his position when they talked to the press.
"Because the Court concludes that there was a manifest necessity for a mistrial based on the jury's deadlock, a retrial on the murder indictments does not violate Clancy's right not to be placed in double jeopardy," — Judge William Sullivan, via ABC News
Why double jeopardy doesn't apply
Clancy faces three counts of first-degree murder, and she's pleaded not guilty to all three. On Nov. 9, Sullivan threw out the defense's double jeopardy argument. He found "manifest necessity" for the September mistrial. That's a legal standard: it requires every other option for reaching a verdict to be exhausted before a judge can end a trial early.
Sullivan also denied the defense's request for the holdout juror's cellphone records, his jury-selection questionnaire, and other materials. He ruled none of it was relevant to the dismissal motion or to any retrial, and that handing it over would violate juror confidentiality. Separately, he turned down the prosecution's request for a gag order on the attorneys — though he told Reddington he could revisit that if circumstances change.
The charges against Clancy didn't change at the Nov. 16 hearing. Sprague told Sullivan the case still "requires a jury trial," which under Massachusetts law points toward first-degree murder rather than a lesser charge a judge alone could decide. The new trial starts March 29, 2027, with Sullivan presiding again.
In their own words
Sullivan didn't hedge on double jeopardy. "Because the Court concludes that there was a manifest necessity for a mistrial based on the jury's deadlock, a retrial on the murder indictments does not violate Clancy's right not to be placed in double jeopardy," he wrote in his ruling, according to ABC News.
On the request to dig into the holdout juror, Sullivan was just as direct: allowing it "without the proper basis or justification would be an improper intrusion into this juror's privacy and would serve to discourage citizens from being willing to serve as jurors in the future," ABC News reported.
At the first trial's closing, Sprague tried to keep the jury's eyes on the murders, not the mental-health system. "This case is not about our mental health system or how it treats women. That's a distraction to get you angry and passionate about an important issue, but an issue that's not on trial here," she told jurors, according to NPR.
Reddington wasn't shy about his frustration either. He accused the prosecution of "spinning everyone in the breeze" by staying quiet on retrial plans, WBUR reported. Once the DA's office made clear it wanted a jury trial, he told the court, "The die has been cast." Then he spelled out what that meant: "I think you can read between the lines that when they say that the case is going to require a jury, that it's an indirect comment from the DA that they intend to proceed on first-degree murder indictments."
What Vinnie has said about this case
“When we watched Lindsay Clancy's criminal case, there was a theme that came from Kevin Reddington and it was a theme that everyone talked about that Lindsay Clancy's doctors were horrific.”
Vinnie Politan on his show, “Patrick Clancy's Lawsuit Is Already in Trouble” (October 28, 2026)
“Lindsay Clancy loses again and loses in a big way inside of the courtroom and this is now becoming a routine here for Kevin Reddington.”
Vinnie Politan on his show, “Lindsay Clancy Loses Again” (October 26, 2026)
What happens next
Clancy goes back to trial March 29, 2027, in Plymouth Superior Court, still facing three counts of first-degree murder, with Judge William Sullivan on the bench again. Prosecutors haven't said whether they'll change their approach this time. The defense is expected to make the same argument it made the first time: that postpartum psychosis left Clancy without criminal responsibility for the killings.
How this plays in court
Eleven of twelve jurors reportedly leaned toward finding Clancy not criminally responsible the first time around. Any prosecutor retrying this case has to reckon with that number. The Commonwealth likely needs stronger expert testimony, or evidence that undercuts the postpartum psychosis timeline, rather than running the same case twice.
Expect the defense to lean hard on the medical record again — the documented suicide attempts, the hospital release weeks before the killings, the medication history. The argument will be the same one as before: Clancy could not distinguish right from wrong at the time, even though her attorneys have never disputed that she killed the children.
This double jeopardy ruling reaches beyond the motion itself. By finding "manifest necessity" for the mistrial, Sullivan made it harder for the defense to get an appellate court to block the retrial before it even starts — that standard is intentionally tough to meet.
A jury, not a judge, will again have to weigh conflicting testimony about Clancy's mental state against the prosecution's theory: that she planned the killings by waiting until she was alone with the children. That's the same split that deadlocked the first jury.
- ABC News - Breaking News, Latest News and Videos: Judge denies Lindsay Clancy's motion to dismiss case
- CNN: Judge denies Lindsay Clancy’s motion to dismiss murder charges, paving the way for potential retrial
- CBS News: Lindsay Clancy trial judge denies motion to dismiss, says there will be no gag order
- NPR: Lindsay Clancy to face a new trial in spring of 2027 over children’s killing
- WBUR: Judge sets March date for Lindsay Clancy to face new trial