Plymouth Superior Court

Prosecutors Still Weighing Whether To Retry Lindsay Clancy

· How we report

Eleven jurors wanted to find her not guilty by reason of insanity. One wouldn't budge. Now the Massachusetts mother accused of killing her three children in 2023 is waiting to find out if prosecutors will put her through a second trial.

Case at a glance

  • Lindsay Clancy — subject

Next: Sullivan has a status hearing set for Nov. 16, 2026, according to NBC News and the Guardian, where he's expected to formally rule on the remaining motions and lock in a specific retrial date. He's signaled March 2027 as his target. The Plymouth County District Attorney's Office still hasn't said whether it will retry Clancy, on what charges, or whether it might reach for a lesser charge like manslaughter instead of murder, per KSNV.

Every report on the Lindsay Clancy case →

Prosecutors Still Weighing Whether To Retry Lindsay Clancy

A father came home to find them

Cora was 5. Dawson was 3. Callan was 8 months old. On the evening of Jan. 24, 2023, inside the family's home in Duxbury, Massachusetts, Lindsay Clancy strangled all three of her children with exercise bands, according to NBC News. She has never disputed that she killed them, the Guardian reported.

Then she went to a second-story bedroom window and jumped. Authorities have described it as a suicide attempt, according to NBC News. She survived it. She is paralyzed now and uses a wheelchair.

Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
Vinnie Uncensored: one free email every Sunday.

Her then-husband, Patrick Clancy, found them. He'd been out running errands and came home to the scene that night. He later testified about it for the prosecution, NBC News reported. A Plymouth County grand jury indicted Lindsay Clancy on charges of murder and strangulation in the deaths of all three children, according to the Serpa Law Office's account of the court record.

The judge, the lawyers, the holdout

Lindsay Clancy is 36. She and Patrick Clancy were married when their children died. He has since filed a separate civil suit against her doctors, alleging that misdiagnoses and prescription medications made her condition worse, per NBC News.

Judge William Sullivan is hearing the case in Plymouth Superior Court, and he's on the clock himself. Sullivan faces mandatory retirement in June 2027, a deadline defense attorney Kevin Reddington has cited in pushing for a fast retrial, according to the Guardian.

Clancy's defense is led by Reddington and Martin Weinberg, the same lawyer who fought Karen Read's double jeopardy battle before the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, per the Serpa Law Office. Jennifer Sprague, a Plymouth County assistant district attorney, is arguing the case for the Commonwealth.

The lone holdout from the first trial has a name now: Michael Péguy Desronvil, identified in court filings and news coverage. Roni Carlson served as the jury's foreperson.

"Based on all the physical evidence, key witnesses and what the prosecution presents, I thought it was enough proof that she knew exactly what she was doing and planned." — Michael Péguy Desronvil, holdout juror, to the Guardian

One signature short of a verdict

Jury selection opened in July 2026, and the trial drew national attention almost immediately. Online conspiracy theories claimed Patrick Clancy, not Lindsay, had killed the children. His lawyers called those claims a "campaign of misinformation" built on "outright falsehoods," and said law enforcement had been notified, per NBC News.

At trial, Reddington argued Clancy was in the grip of postpartum psychosis and hearing voices when she killed the children. Prosecutors countered that she wasn't psychotic at all that night. She acted deliberately, they said, and she understood what she was doing was wrong, according to the Guardian.

The jury deliberated for more than 38 hours over seven days. Three separate times, they told the judge they couldn't reach a verdict, according to the Serpa Law Office's account citing WBUR. After the second deadlock report, Sullivan gave them the Tuey-Rodriguez instruction, telling jurors in the minority and the majority to reconsider their positions without abandoning their own honest judgment.

On Sept. 3, 2026, the foreperson reported that one juror wasn't following the court's instructions on reasonable doubt. Sullivan questioned each juror individually, got assurances from all twelve that they could follow the law, and declared a mistrial the next day anyway.

News organizations have described the split as 11-1: eleven jurors favoring a verdict of not guilty by reason of lack of criminal responsibility — Massachusetts' version of an insanity verdict — and one, Desronvil, holding out for guilty.

Carlson, the foreperson, told NBC10 what that moment felt like. The holdout juror "admitted he had reasonable doubt, and I started filling out the forms, I was so excited," she said, according to the Guardian. "There were three forms I had to fill out and I started filling them out, I wrote my signature on each one, and then he said: 'But I'm still not going to say that she's not guilty by reason of insanity,'" she said.

Why a second trial is allowed

On Nov. 2, 2026, Clancy's lawyers asked Sullivan to throw out the murder charges entirely, arguing a second trial would violate her constitutional protection against double jeopardy. Weinberg argued Sullivan should have questioned the holdout juror more closely before calling the mistrial. Done right, he said, that inquiry might have let deliberations continue with an alternate juror instead, according to NBC News.

Sprague, for the prosecution, argued Sullivan handled the deadlock exactly right, and that singling out one juror for individual questioning would have improperly exposed the jury's private deliberations. The Commonwealth also asked Sullivan for a gag order on the lawyers and law enforcement, pointing to Reddington's public remark that he hoped the holdout juror could "sleep well at night," which Sprague called "calculated to affect the public's perception of the case," the Guardian reported.

Sullivan denied both motions, CNN reported — no dismissal, no gag order. He ruled that the mistrial met the "manifest necessity" standard, a high legal bar meaning every realistic alternative to a verdict had already been tried and exhausted. Retrying Clancy, he found, would not violate double jeopardy.

In his written ruling, Sullivan found that "the foreperson's notes did not plausibly suggest that Juror Doe refused to consider the trial evidence or disagreed with the law as explained by the Court in its instructions," according to CNN. He also turned down the defense's request for the holdout juror's cellphone records and jury questionnaire, finding them irrelevant to the dismissal motion.

Sullivan had already denied an earlier defense motion once, filed under state court rules right after the mistrial. That motion asked him to simply enter a finding of not guilty. He ruled on Oct. 1, 2026, that prosecutors had presented enough evidence for a jury to find Clancy guilty and criminally responsible, according to the Serpa Law Office, citing Boston 25 News.

Sullivan said he's inclined to set a March 2027 trial date. The Plymouth County District Attorney's Office, though, still hasn't said whether it will retry Clancy at all, or on what charges, CNN reported. KSNV reported that prosecutors, the defense and the court are still working through whether jury selection would look different the second time, whether Clancy would testify, and whether prosecutors might add lesser charges like manslaughter.

In their own words

Desronvil, the holdout, put it plainly in a statement after the mistrial. He "didn't have any doubts" during deliberations. "Based on all the physical evidence, key witnesses and what the prosecution presents, I thought it was enough proof that she knew exactly what she was doing and planned," he said, according to the Guardian.

Sprague told the court the holdout's stance was about the evidence, not bias. "It is clear from the record that this juror did not refuse to deliberate," she said. "He refused to agree," the Guardian reported.

Reddington has made no secret of wanting this over fast. "I am not going to have this woman sit incarcerated for the next year or two or three," he said. "I want a trial and I want it with you and I want it this spring," according to the Guardian.

Weinberg told Sullivan a deeper inquiry into the holdout juror could have changed the outcome of the entire first trial. "A probing voir dire could have disclosed that the 12th juror was not following instructions," he said, according to the Serpa Law Office's account citing CBS Boston.

The DA's office declined to comment on any of it, CNN reported, and still hasn't said publicly whether it intends to put Clancy on trial again.

Vinnie on air

What Vinnie has said about this case

“When we watched Lindsay Clancy's criminal case, there was a theme that came from Kevin Reddington and it was a theme that everyone talked about that Lindsay Clancy's doctors were horrific.”

Vinnie Politan on his show, “Patrick Clancy's Lawsuit Is Already in Trouble” (October 28, 2026)

“Lindsay Clancy loses again and loses in a big way inside of the courtroom and this is now becoming a routine here for Kevin Reddington.”

Vinnie Politan on his show, “Lindsay Clancy Loses Again” (October 26, 2026)

What happens next

Sullivan has a status hearing set for Nov. 16, 2026, according to NBC News and the Guardian, where he's expected to formally rule on the remaining motions and lock in a specific retrial date. He's signaled March 2027 as his target. The Plymouth County District Attorney's Office still hasn't said whether it will retry Clancy, on what charges, or whether it might reach for a lesser charge like manslaughter instead of murder, per KSNV.

The legal read

How this plays in court

The manifest necessity finding clears the double jeopardy obstacle. Prosecutors can retry Clancy on the same murder and strangulation charges. What they still have to figure out is whether the same evidence and the same strategy can push a new jury past the exact point where the last one got stuck.

Eleven of twelve jurors leaned toward not guilty by reason of lack of criminal responsibility last time. That split is the risk sitting at the center of this decision, and it may be why KSNV reported prosecutors are weighing a lesser charge like manslaughter as a hedge against another deadlock.

Expect the defense to run largely the same postpartum psychosis narrative, but push for different jury selection procedures and maybe a bench trial if the charges get reduced. Patrick Clancy's account of what he found that night will anchor the prosecution's timeline again.

Any new jury will have to weigh the same core legal question the last one split on: whether Clancy understood her conduct was wrong under Massachusetts' insanity standard. The mistrial proved that question alone can divide reasonable jurors, even when nobody disputes that the killings happened.

Sources. This report draws on the following coverage; quotes are reproduced as those outlets printed them.
  • KSNV: Judge eyes March for possible Lindsay Clancy retrial as prosecutors weigh next steps
  • The Guardian: Lindsay Clancy back in court seeking to dismiss murder charges after mistrial
  • CNN: Judge denies Lindsay Clancy’s motion to dismiss murder charges, paving the way for potential retrial
  • NBC News: Judge is weighing a retrial for Lindsay Clancy in the deaths of her three children
  • Serpa Law Office: Lindsay Clancy Hearing on November 2, 2026 and the Double Jeopardy Motion
Vinnie Politan is a former prosecutor and veteran trial anchor.
Vinnie Uncensored · every Sunday
Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
One email every Sunday: the week's biggest cases, the real charges, nothing softened. Free. Unsubscribe anytime.