HEARING

Federal Judge Says Jury May Have Gotten It Wrong In Tulsa Man's Life Sentence For Killing

· How we report

A federal judge has agreed to hold a hearing on whether Channen Smith was wrongfully convicted in a 2010 Tulsa killing. U.S. District Judge Sara Hill ruled that a juror today would more likely than not have reasonable doubt about his guilt.

Case at a glance

  • Channen Smith — Oklahoma prisoner pursuing innocence claim, convicted
  • Dominique Jasper — man killed outside north Tulsa home, victim
  • Carlameisha Jefferson — woman wounded in the shooting, victim
  • Sara Hill — U.S. District Judge who ordered the hearing, official

Next: Mark March 2027. That's when the four-day evidentiary hearing before Judge Hill, originally set for Nov. 9, finally happens. Smith's attorneys at Smolen and Associates and the Oklahoma Attorney General's Office will lay out testimony and evidence on whether the 2013 conviction should stand or fall. Until then, Smith stays in prison, serving out his life-plus-40-year sentence.

Federal Judge Says Jury May Have Gotten It Wrong In Tulsa Man's Life Sentence For Killing

Gunfire outside a north Tulsa home

Gunfire tore through the dark outside a north Tulsa home in the early hours of Oct. 23, 2010. Two people went down: Carlameisha Jefferson and Dominique Jasper.

Jefferson survived her wounds. Jasper didn't. He died in the hospital 23 days later.

Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
Vinnie Uncensored: one free email every Sunday.

Prosecutors told the jury the shooting didn't come out of nowhere. It grew from an old argument and a romantic feud, a dispute that, they said, put Channen Smith behind the wheel, driving to the house to open fire on the people inside.

A Tulsa County jury believed it. In 2013, jurors convicted Smith of first-degree murder for killing Jasper, plus related firearm charges. He's been in prison on that conviction for about thirteen years now.

The victim, the survivor, the convicted

Dominique Jasper didn't survive the shooting. Carlameisha Jefferson did — she was hit alongside him and lived.

Channen Smith is the man a jury sent to prison for it. He has said for years, through a federal habeas corpus petition, that he didn't pull the trigger, and he filed that petition himself, without a lawyer. Oklahoma Watch picked up the case back at that pro se stage, a detail that matters: claims like this rarely survive long enough to land on a federal judge's docket.

Sara Hill is the U.S. District Judge now holding that docket. The Tulsa firm Smolen and Associates stepped in to represent Smith in July 2025. On the other side sits the Oklahoma Attorney General's Office, arguing the conviction should stand.

"A reasonable juror confronted with the newly supplemented record more likely than not would have reasonable doubt about Smith's guilt," — U.S. District Judge Sara Hill, in her April 2025 order, per Oklahoma Watch.

The sentence that keeps Smith in prison

A judge accepted the jury's recommendation and handed Smith life in prison for first-degree murder, the killing of Jasper. Oklahoma law allows three outcomes for that charge: life, life without parole, or death. The jury chose life, and the judge followed its lead.

That wasn't the only number attached to his name. Smith also got 20 years for shooting with intent to kill, tied to Jefferson's wounding. Then 10 years for firing a gun into a dwelling, since the house itself took the bullets. And 10 more for being a felon in possession of a firearm. That charge required proving Smith had a prior felony conviction and still had access to a gun that night.

Add it up and the sentence comes to life plus 40 years. In plain terms: Smith doesn't walk out of prison unless the murder conviction itself falls.

What changed Judge Hill's mind

Getting here took years. Smith's pro se habeas petition kept moving forward, and Oklahoma Watch reported on that progress more than a year ago, which was notable on its own. Federal courts hold inmates to strict procedural and evidentiary standards when they try to challenge a conviction that already survived trial and appeal. Before Smith could even bring his claim to federal court, he had to exhaust his options in Oklahoma's own courts first, through what's called a direct appeal. The available coverage doesn't detail how that process played out.

Federal habeas law puts a steep hurdle in front of every prisoner trying to reopen a case. A court won't even look at new evidence unless it clears what's called a 'gateway' actual innocence claim. That means showing a reasonable juror, seeing this evidence, would not have convicted him. Almost nobody clears that bar. Federal courts grant it rarely, and only when the new evidence is reliable, points to innocence, and wasn't available at the original trial. In April 2025, Judge Hill ruled that Smith had cleared it anyway.

How close does Hill think this case really is? Close enough to write this: 'A reasonable juror confronted with the newly supplemented record more likely than not would have reasonable doubt about Smith's guilt.' Then she ordered the state of Oklahoma to respond to the claim.

None of that makes Smith innocent. It means a federal court decided his evidence was strong enough to earn a hearing instead of leaving the 2013 verdict alone. What exactly is in that 'newly supplemented record'? Oklahoma Watch's reporting doesn't say. All that's clear is that whatever it holds was enough to shift a federal judge's read of the case.

What both sides aren't saying

So far, the loudest voice in this case belongs to Hill herself, her order is the clearest public statement anyone has made. Smith hasn't spoken publicly. Neither have his attorneys at Smolen and Associates, and neither has the Oklahoma Attorney General's Office.

The court record still shows where each side stands. Smith's new legal team is pushing the actual-innocence claim that caught Hill's attention. The Attorney General's Office is defending the verdict a Tulsa County jury reached back in 2013. Staying quiet while a federal case is pending is normal enough. But it means nobody outside the courtroom will see the full reasoning on either side until the 2027 hearing.

A hearing delayed again, now March 2027

Hill had set a four-day evidentiary hearing to start Nov. 9, with both sides laying out testimony on Smith's innocence claim. Both sides get to call witnesses and introduce evidence. Then it's up to Hill: she'll decide whether the new record is strong enough to undo the 2013 verdict.

That date is gone now. A death in the family of one of the attorneys on the case pushed the hearing back to March 2027. Smith stays in prison while the clock resets. If Hill eventually decides his evidence meets the higher constitutional bar for actual innocence, she could order a new trial or his release. If she doesn't, the convictions stand, and Smith keeps serving his sentence.

What happens next

Mark March 2027. That's when the four-day evidentiary hearing before Judge Hill, originally set for Nov. 9, finally happens. Smith's attorneys at Smolen and Associates and the Oklahoma Attorney General's Office will lay out testimony and evidence on whether the 2013 conviction should stand or fall. Until then, Smith stays in prison, serving out his life-plus-40-year sentence.

The legal read

How this plays in court

Any prosecutor reviewing this record is going to want one thing first: what exactly makes up the 'newly supplemented record' Hill cited. What specific evidence or testimony, beyond what the 2013 jury ever saw, is driving a federal judge's doubt?

The defense has a gift here, and it's Hill's own language. A sitting federal judge reviewed the trial record and concluded a reasonable juror today could have reasonable doubt about guilt. That's rare. Expect it to frame every argument Smolen and Associates makes at the March 2027 hearing.

The burden sits with the Oklahoma Attorney General's Office now. They have to persuade Hill the 2013 verdict should stand, even though her own preliminary read of the record already found reasonable doubt more likely than not.

Back in 2013, a jury weighed the state's theory: a romantic feud behind a drive-by shooting outside the home where Jasper and Jefferson were struck. Whatever new evidence exists now gets tested against that same motive theory at the hearing.

Sources. This report draws on the following coverage; quotes are reproduced as those outlets printed them.
  • Oklahoma Watch: Federal Judge Says Jury May Have Gotten It Wrong In Tulsa Man's Life Sentence For Killing
Vinnie Politan is a former prosecutor and veteran trial anchor.
Vinnie Uncensored · every Sunday
Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
One email every Sunday: the week's biggest cases, the real charges, nothing softened. Free. Unsubscribe anytime.