Plymouth Superior Court

Lindsay Clancy Set For Second Trial On Homicide Charges

· How we report

Cora was 5. Dawson was 3. Callan was 8 months old. All three died in the basement of their family's Duxbury home — and on Monday, a Plymouth County judge told their mother she'll face trial again. Judge Sullivan set the retrial for March 29, 2027, rejecting Lindsay Clancy's bid to dismiss the three first-degree murder charges. Prosecutors still haven't said whether they'll pursue the same charges that left a jury deadlocked in September.

Case at a glance

  • Lindsay Clancy — subject

Next: Clancy is back in court Feb. 18, 2027, for a pretrial hearing to nail down logistics. The retrial itself is set for March 29, 2027, on the same three counts of first-degree murder, Judge Sullivan has ruled. Before that date arrives, the Plymouth County District Attorney's Office still has to decide, publicly, whether it's keeping those charges or stepping down to something lesser — second-degree murder, maybe manslaughter.

Every report on the Lindsay Clancy case →

Lindsay Clancy Set For Second Trial On Homicide Charges

Three children dead, a jury stuck

Cora was five. Dawson was three. Callan hadn't turned one. On Jan. 24, 2023, Lindsay Clancy strangled all three of her children with exercise bands in the basement of the family's home in Duxbury, Massachusetts. No one at trial disputed that she did it, according to the Guardian and CNN.

Then she turned the violence on herself. Clancy cut herself with a knife and jumped from a second-story window, trying to end her own life. She survived. She is paralyzed now, the Guardian and RadarOnline reported.

Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
Vinnie Uncensored: one free email every Sunday.

This year, she stood trial on three counts of first-degree murder. Jury selection started in late July 2026. Nine women and three men sat on the panel. They deliberated more than 38 hours before Judge William Sullivan declared a mistrial on Sept. 4, 2026, after jurors told him they were deadlocked, CNN reported.

Monday, Sullivan denied Clancy's motion to dismiss the charges outright, then turned to the calendar. He floated April 5 first. Prosecutors said they couldn't be ready until May — their docket was already full of other cases. Reddington said late April worked fine for him. After more back-and-forth, Sullivan circled back to his original instinct and landed on March 29, 2027, over the prosecution's objection, RadarOnline reported. A pretrial hearing is set for Feb. 18 to work out the logistics.

The people who fill this courtroom

Lindsay Clancy is 36. She's the Duxbury mother charged with three counts of first-degree murder in the deaths of her children.

Cora was 5. Dawson was 3. Callan was 8 months old. All three died in the January 2023 attack.

Patrick Clancy, her husband and the children's father, testified at the first trial. The New York Post reported prosecutors may be weighing his wishes as they decide whether to retry the case.

Judge William Sullivan is presiding over the case in Plymouth Superior Court. He's approaching mandatory retirement in June 2027. Kevin Reddington represents Clancy. Timothy Cruz is the Plymouth County district attorney, and Jennifer Sprague is one of the assistant district attorneys trying the case.

Michael Péguy Desronvil was the lone holdout juror in the first trial. His attorney, Heather O'Connor, has defended his conduct against the defense's accusations.

"We're here at this courthouse today because those children are not," — Timothy Cruz, Plymouth County district attorney

What the judge actually decided Monday

Sullivan rejected Clancy's argument that trying her again would violate her constitutional protection against double jeopardy — being tried twice for the same crime. He found "manifest necessity" for the September mistrial, a high legal bar that means every other option for reaching a verdict had been exhausted, CNN reported.

He also denied Clancy's request to question the holdout juror under oath or pull his phone records and jury questionnaire. The evidence, Sullivan ruled, "is not relevant and material to her defense at any retrial," according to RadarOnline.

In a third ruling, Sullivan turned down the prosecution's request for a gag order that would have barred both sides from talking to reporters. He left the door open, though — prosecutors can ask again if circumstances change, CNN reported.

The two outcomes here couldn't be further apart. A first-degree murder conviction in Massachusetts carries a mandatory sentence of life in prison without parole, the Guardian reported. A verdict of not guilty by reason of lack of criminal responsibility — the state's version of an insanity defense — would send Clancy to a state psychiatric hospital instead. She'd be subject to regular court review there.

The one vote that split the jury

After the mistrial, several jurors came forward. Eleven of the 12, they said, were ready to find Clancy not guilty by reason of lack of criminal responsibility. One juror wouldn't budge — later identified publicly as Michael Péguy Desronvil, CNN and RadarOnline reported.

Reddington argued Desronvil lied his way onto the jury — he never disclosed a 2021 domestic violence arrest that was later dismissed. O'Connor, Desronvil's attorney, pushed back. She said he checked a box on his questionnaire flagging past legal involvement, and it was Reddington's job to follow up, not Desronvil's to volunteer more. Reddington, she said, is simply upset that Desronvil "did not vote the way the defense needed."

Sullivan sided with prosecutors on this one. The foreperson's notes, he found, didn't show Desronvil ever refused to deliberate or ignored the court's instructions, CNN reported.

The charge nobody will name yet

Months later, the Plymouth County District Attorney's Office still won't say it out loud. Will Cruz's office retry Clancy on the same three counts of first-degree murder? Or go lower — second-degree murder, maybe manslaughter? Multiple outlets reported the silence continues.

Reddington has pushed Cruz to downgrade the charges. In court, he accused prosecutors of "(spinning) everyone in the breeze" by refusing to reveal their decision, CNN reported.

One thing may be weighing on Cruz, according to the New York Post: the overturned conviction of Latarsha Sanders. Her case was also prosecuted by his office and presided over by the same judge. It got reversed last summer after her mental health history was excluded from trial despite an insanity defense. Boston attorney Brad Bailey framed the dilemma this way: "Are they to be consistent? Will they need to also offer proceeding under murder two in the other case, or are they going to open a floodgate, and do they want to take a hard line?"

Boston defense attorney Elyse Hershon doesn't expect him to budge. "He will try first-degree any time that he can. I do not see him getting dissuaded by public support for Clancy or the focus on a failure of the mental health system," she told CNN. "He's focused on the three children."

Former federal prosecutor Sarah Krissoff told the New York Post the case "has people who are very vehemently committed to either side and DAs are political creatures. They are elected," suggesting the timing could carry political weight. Defense attorney Peter Elikann sees it differently. Cruz "is very popular. He has been re-elected many times, and I really give him credit for having integrity that he would not let his decisions as a prosecutor be dictated by what might be politically popular," Elikann said.

The words each side chose

Sullivan didn't pretend the first trial was easy. In his written ruling, he wrote: "The Court understands the frustration of the defendant and the jurors that despite the utmost diligence, the jury ultimately was unable to reach a verdict in this emotionally grueling and complicated case," according to RadarOnline.

After the mistrial, DA Cruz stood outside the courthouse and told reporters, "We're here at this courthouse today because those children are not," adding that one of a prosecutor's most important functions is to "speak for the victims who are no longer here," CNN reported.

Assistant DA Jennifer Sprague was more guarded at an earlier hearing. Whether to retry the case, she told the judge, would "depend" on his rulings on the pending motions. "We're not at that point yet," she said, per CNN.

Northeastern law professor Daniel Medwed told CNN the hearing mattered, but it didn't settle anything. "Monday will be significant in that it would be a signal about the prosecution's big picture decision about whether it wants to pursue criminal charges as opposed to dismissing them. But what happens on Monday is the beginning, not the end, because a lot of different things could happen in the run-up to trial."

Vinnie on air

What Vinnie has said about this case

“When we watched Lindsay Clancy's criminal case, there was a theme that came from Kevin Reddington and it was a theme that everyone talked about that Lindsay Clancy's doctors were horrific.”

Vinnie Politan on his show, “Patrick Clancy's Lawsuit Is Already in Trouble” (October 28, 2026)

“Lindsay Clancy loses again and loses in a big way inside of the courtroom and this is now becoming a routine here for Kevin Reddington.”

Vinnie Politan on his show, “Lindsay Clancy Loses Again” (October 26, 2026)

What happens next

Clancy is back in court Feb. 18, 2027, for a pretrial hearing to nail down logistics. The retrial itself is set for March 29, 2027, on the same three counts of first-degree murder, Judge Sullivan has ruled. Before that date arrives, the Plymouth County District Attorney's Office still has to decide, publicly, whether it's keeping those charges or stepping down to something lesser — second-degree murder, maybe manslaughter.

The legal read

How this plays in court

The math from the first trial doesn't go away. Eleven of 12 jurors reportedly leaned toward finding Clancy not guilty by reason of lack of criminal responsibility. Whatever Cruz's office decides now — stick with first-degree murder, or step down to second-degree murder or manslaughter — will shape how a second jury hears the exact same facts.

Expect Reddington to keep hammering on the holdout juror's undisclosed 2021 arrest, arguing the mistrial itself was flawed. Twice now, the judge has refused to let Clancy's team examine the juror's records or put him under oath.

Nobody disputes that Clancy killed her children. That was never the question. The job for a second jury is the same as it was the first time. They have to decide whether her documented postpartum psychosis cleared Massachusetts' legal threshold for lack of criminal responsibility at the moment she acted.

There's outside pressure too: the overturned conviction of Latarsha Sanders. Same office, same judge, and excluding mental-health evidence from that trial proved fatal on appeal. That precedent could push Cruz toward a charging decision he can defend as consistent across both cases.

Sources. This report draws on the following coverage; quotes are reproduced as those outlets printed them.
  • New York Post: Lindsay Clancy prosecutor has been silent on trying her again — and there may be one surprising reason why
  • RadarOnline: Lindsay Clancy Set to Face Retrial in 2027 for Killing Her Children
  • The Guardian: Judge clears way for Lindsay Clancy to be retried on murder charges
  • CNN: Judge denies Lindsay Clancy’s motion to dismiss murder charges, paving the way for potential retrial
  • NBC Boston: Lindsay Clancy loses bid to dismiss murder charges, question ‘holdout juror'
  • CNN: Lindsay Clancy due in court for a hearing that should determine what her retrial may look like
Vinnie Politan is a former prosecutor and veteran trial anchor.
Vinnie Uncensored · every Sunday
Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
One email every Sunday: the week's biggest cases, the real charges, nothing softened. Free. Unsubscribe anytime.