RETRIAL

Lindsay Clancy Could Skip A Retrial And Plead Guilty In Her Children's Deaths, Analyst Says

· How we report

Lindsay Clancy walked back into a Massachusetts courtroom today. Prosecutors have to decide whether to retry her on three counts of first-degree murder in her children's deaths. Or offer a lesser charge that would let her plead guilty and skip a second trial entirely.

Case at a glance

  • Lindsay Clancy — defendant, accused
  • Tim Cruz — Plymouth County District Attorney, official
  • William Sullivan — Plymouth Superior Court Judge, official
  • Kevin Reddington — defense attorney for Lindsay Clancy
  • Jennifer Roman — WBZ-TV legal analyst

Next: Clancy showed up in Plymouth Superior Court on Monday, Nov. 16, the date Judge Sullivan set for both sides to address what comes next. If prosecutors move forward on the original first-degree murder charges, or if Clancy's team rejects a reduced charge, the court is expected to start scheduling a second trial. The Guardian and CT Insider report that could begin as soon as March. If prosecutors offer a lesser charge instead, the next question becomes simple: do Clancy and Reddington take the plea, or press ahead to a second trial on those reduced counts?

Every report on the Lindsay Clancy case →

Lindsay Clancy Could Skip A Retrial And Plead Guilty In Her Children's Deaths, Analyst Says

A basement in Duxbury, January 2023

Cora was 5. Dawson was 3. Callan was 8 months old. Prosecutors say their mother, Lindsay Clancy, strangled all three with exercise bands in the basement of the family's home in Duxbury, Massachusetts, on Jan. 24, 2023. Her husband, Patrick Clancy, was out running errands at the time, according to CT Insider.

No one at her first trial disputed that she killed them, the Guardian reported. Afterward, Clancy cut herself with a knife and jumped from a second-story window, an apparent attempt to end her own life. It left her paralyzed.

Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
Vinnie Uncensored: one free email every Sunday.

She was charged with three counts of first-degree murder.

The nurse, the lawyer and the judge

Lindsay Clancy spent her career delivering babies. She's 36, grew up in Wallingford, Connecticut, and worked as a labor and delivery nurse, according to CT Insider and WHDH.

Her attorney, Kevin Reddington, hasn't disputed that she killed her children. His defense is that she shouldn't be held criminally responsible for it. Plymouth Superior Court Judge William Sullivan is overseeing the case; he's set to retire in June 2027, per CBS News. Plymouth County District Attorney Tim Cruz and Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague represent the prosecution.

Three people outside the case have become its loudest voices: WBZ-TV legal analyst Jennifer Roman, Northeastern University law professor Daniel Medwed and Boston defense attorney Elyse Hershon. None of them represent Clancy or the state. All three have been quoted widely explaining what today's hearing could mean.

"Which if they did do that, if they knocked it down to second degree murder, or even manslaughter, Lindsay Clancy would have the opportunity to plead guilty, which would avoid a trial all around." — Jennifer Roman, WBZ-TV legal analyst, to CBS News

A jury splits 11-1, then a mistrial

Reddington never argued his client didn't do it. Instead, he told the jury Clancy was overmedicated and suffering from postpartum psychosis. It was bad enough, he argued, that she should be found not criminally responsible, which is Massachusetts' version of an insanity defense, according to CBS News and the Guardian. Prosecutors pushed back hard: Clancy knew right from wrong, they said, and she'd planned to strangle her children, per CBS News.

Nine women and three men sat on that jury. They deadlocked 11-1. Several jurors later said publicly that one holdout kept them from reaching a not-guilty-by-reason-of-lack-of-criminal-responsibility verdict, the Guardian reported. Sullivan declared a mistrial on Sept. 4.

Clancy's defense didn't stop there. They moved to dismiss the case outright. They argued a retrial would violate her protection against double jeopardy, and that Sullivan should have questioned or removed the holdout juror rather than call a mistrial. Sullivan denied that motion. He ruled there was manifest necessity for the mistrial, and that a second trial wouldn't unconstitutionally try Clancy twice for the same crime, according to the Guardian and Yahoo/TMZ.

The judge also turned down a separate defense request: the holdout juror's cellphone records and confidential questionnaire. He found the material wasn't relevant to the dismissal motion. And he rejected a prosecution request to bar Clancy's lawyers from speaking publicly about the case, per Yahoo/TMZ.

Life without parole, or a way out

Life without parole. That's the mandatory sentence for a first-degree murder conviction in Massachusetts, the Guardian reported. It's also the weight hanging over Tim Cruz's decision: retry Clancy on those same three counts, or bring something lesser, like second-degree murder or manslaughter.

The choice matters well beyond the courtroom. A lesser charge would open the door for Clancy to plead guilty and skip a second trial entirely, WBZ-TV legal analyst Jennifer Roman told CBS News. Reddington has said before that he'd never accept any deal that puts her in jail.

If Clancy is retried on a reduced charge, she'd also get a choice jurors don't usually offer defendants. A judge, instead of a jury, could decide the case, CBS News reported. No new trial date has been set as of this week. Judge Sullivan has floated March as a possibility, according to the Guardian and CT Insider.

In their own words, on the record

"I expect the prosecution is going to announce [today] that they are going to proceed again with three counts of first-degree murder. They may choose to do something different than that, they may seek to pursue a lesser charge," Roman told CBS News. Then came the stakes in plain terms: "Which if they did do that, if they knocked it down to second degree murder, or even manslaughter, Lindsay Clancy would have the opportunity to plead guilty, which would avoid a trial all around."

Cruz has kept the focus on the victims. "We're here at this courthouse today because those children are not," he told reporters after the mistrial was declared, according to ABC7/CNN. Asked about the timing of a decision, he said, "There's all sorts of things we're waiting on, including judicial decisions," according to WHDH.

Medwed told CNN the hearing "would be a signal about the prosecution's big picture decision about whether it wants to pursue criminal charges as opposed to dismissing them," but cautioned, "what happens on Monday is the beginning, not the end, because a lot of different things could happen in the run-up to trial." Reddington, for his part, has accused prosecutors of "spinning everyone in the breeze" over their delay in announcing a decision, per ABC7/CNN.

Vinnie on air

What Vinnie has said about this case

“When we watched Lindsay Clancy's criminal case, there was a theme that came from Kevin Reddington and it was a theme that everyone talked about that Lindsay Clancy's doctors were horrific.”

Vinnie Politan on his show, “Patrick Clancy's Lawsuit Is Already in Trouble” (October 28, 2026)

“Lindsay Clancy loses again and loses in a big way inside of the courtroom and this is now becoming a routine here for Kevin Reddington.”

Vinnie Politan on his show, “Lindsay Clancy Loses Again” (October 26, 2026)

What happens next

Clancy showed up in Plymouth Superior Court on Monday, Nov. 16, the date Judge Sullivan set for both sides to address what comes next. If prosecutors move forward on the original first-degree murder charges, or if Clancy's team rejects a reduced charge, the court is expected to start scheduling a second trial. The Guardian and CT Insider report that could begin as soon as March. If prosecutors offer a lesser charge instead, the next question becomes simple: do Clancy and Reddington take the plea, or press ahead to a second trial on those reduced counts?

The legal read

How this plays in court

An 11-1 deadlock puts prosecutors in a bind. They have to judge whether a new jury would hear the same postpartum psychosis evidence any differently. Or whether that near-unanimous result signals the case is better resolved short of a full second trial.

Expect the defense to run the same core argument. Clancy was overmedicated, they'll say, and suffering from psychosis severe enough that she couldn't appreciate the wrongfulness of her conduct. Under Massachusetts law, that would mean she lacked criminal responsibility, not that she didn't commit the killings.

A reduced charge changes the math. Second-degree murder or manslaughter means a judge or jury weighs premeditation and state of mind against a lower evidentiary bar than first-degree murder. That's likely the lever prosecutors are considering to get a guilty plea without re-trying the case from scratch.

Don't count out the holdout juror's records yet. Those denied defense motions could resurface on appeal if there's a conviction at a second trial, since the defense already argued the mistrial itself was declared too soon.

Sources. This report draws on the following coverage; quotes are reproduced as those outlets printed them.
  • CBS News: Lindsay Clancy Could Skip A Retrial And Plead Guilty In Her Children's Deaths, Analyst Says
  • ABC7 Bay Area: Lindsay Clancy trial update: Massachusetts mother due in court for a hearing that should determine what her retrial may look like
  • CT Insider: Lindsay Clancy could face a second trial. Here's what happens next
  • WHDH: Lindsay Clancy expected in court, potential decision on future of case could be announced
  • Yahoo: Lindsay Clancy Shut Down in Plea to Dismiss Murder Case, Close To Retrial
  • The Guardian: Judge clears way for Lindsay Clancy to be retried on murder charges
Vinnie Politan is a former prosecutor and veteran trial anchor.
Vinnie Uncensored · every Sunday
Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
One email every Sunday: the week's biggest cases, the real charges, nothing softened. Free. Unsubscribe anytime.