Judge Sides With Lindsay Clancy Again, Rejects Bid To Limit What Her Lawyers Can Say
A Massachusetts judge just cleared the path to retry Lindsay Clancy for strangling her three children to death in January 2023. In the same round of rulings, he refused to muzzle her defense lawyers from talking about the case in public.
Case at a glance
- Lindsay Clancy — Duxbury mother accused of killing her three children, accused
- William Sullivan — Judge, Plymouth County, official
Next: Both sides are back in Plymouth Superior Court on November 16, 2026, to hash out scheduling for a second trial. Sullivan wants the retrial underway by March 2027. What prosecutors haven't said: whether they'll bring the same murder charges, go for something lesser like manslaughter, or try to cut a plea deal. They could also come back and ask for that gag order again, if Clancy's lawyers keep talking in a way prosecutors think could poison the jury pool.

Three children gone, one mother who survived
Cora was 5. Dawson was 3. Callan was 8 months old. On January 24, 2023, inside the family's home in Duxbury, Massachusetts, their mother, Lindsay Clancy, strangled all three, according to prosecutors. Clancy has never disputed that she killed them.
Then Clancy went to the window. She jumped from the second floor in what authorities have called a suicide attempt, and she survived — but she's been partially paralyzed ever since. CNN reports she's been held at Tewksbury Hospital since shortly after her children died.
Clancy used to deliver other people's babies. She was a labor and delivery nurse before she was a defendant. This past summer, she stood trial on murder charges in Plymouth Superior Court, where testimony ran more than a month. Much of it zeroed in on her psychiatric history and what was going on in her mind the night her children died.
Jurors started deliberating in late August. By September 4, 2026, the 12 of them told Judge William Sullivan they couldn't agree. He declared a mistrial. The vote, it later came out, was 11-1 — eleven jurors leaning not guilty on the grounds that Clancy lacked criminal responsibility, one holdout insisting on guilty.
The lawyers, the judge, the holdout
Lindsay Clancy is 36. She's the Duxbury mother accused of killing her three children — Cora, Dawson and Callan Clancy, the kids who died that night in January.
Judge William Sullivan ran the first trial, and he's overseeing what comes next. He's got a deadline of his own — mandatory retirement hits in June 2027.
Kevin Reddington and Martin Weinberg are defending Clancy. On the other side, Plymouth County Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague is prosecuting the case, under District Attorney Timothy Cruz.
One juror held the whole case up: Michael Péguy Desronvil, the lone holdout. Roni Carlson was the foreperson. When the defense came after Desronvil's phone records once the mistrial was declared, attorney Heather O'Connor represented him.
"Because the court concludes that there was manifest necessity for a mistrial based on the jury's deadlock, a retrial on the murder indictments does not violate Clancy's right not to be placed in double jeopardy," — Judge William Sullivan, per WWBT/Associated Press.
Three rulings that shape what's next
Clancy is charged with murder in her children's deaths — first-degree murder, prosecutors have indicated. They haven't said publicly whether they'll bring the same charges to a retrial. Either way, those charges are still unresolved. The first trial ended without a verdict.
On Monday, Sullivan shut down the defense's bid to dismiss the whole case on double jeopardy grounds. The defense had argued the September mistrial came too fast, and that trying Clancy again would mean prosecuting her twice for the same act. Sullivan didn't buy it. He ruled the jury's deadlock created what the law calls 'manifest necessity' for the mistrial — which means, legally, a retrial doesn't violate Clancy's protection against double jeopardy.
Sullivan also turned down a separate ask — the defense wanted the holdout juror's phone records and questionnaire, plus a chance to question him further about what happened during deliberations. Denied. Plain English: the defense can't use that juror's conduct to block a second trial.
Then came the third ruling. Sullivan denied prosecutors' request for a gag order — one that would have stopped Clancy's attorneys from talking publicly about the case. He denied it without prejudice, so prosecutors can come back and ask again if they can show it's become necessary. For now, Clancy's lawyers are free to keep giving interviews and talking to reporters as the case heads toward a second trial.
What was said, word for word
Sullivan put the double jeopardy question to rest in writing. "Because the court concludes that there was manifest necessity for a mistrial based on the jury's deadlock, a retrial on the murder indictments does not violate Clancy's right not to be placed in double jeopardy," he wrote, according to WWBT and the Associated Press.
Then things got tense. At the hearing, defense attorney Kevin Reddington tried to name the holdout juror — despite a court order keeping him under a pseudonym. "I'm going to stop you right there," Sullivan said. "No, you're not going to stop me," Reddington shot back, the Guardian reported.
Prosecutor Jennifer Sprague pushed back on any suggestion the holdout juror did something wrong. "It is clear from the record that this juror did not refuse to deliberate. He refused to agree," she said, per the Guardian.
Desronvil himself has no regrets. After the mistrial, the holdout juror said he had no doubts about his vote. "Based on all the physical evidence, key witnesses and what the prosecution presents, I thought it was enough proof that she knew exactly what she was doing and planned," he said, according to the Guardian.
Foreperson Roni Carlson says they were close. She told NBC10 the panel was nearly at a not-guilty verdict before the holdout changed his mind. "He admitted he had reasonable doubt, and I started filling out the forms, I was so excited... and then he said: 'But I'm still not going to say that she's not guilty by reason of insanity.'"
Reddington wants this over fast. "I will not have this woman sit in jail for another year or two or three. I want a trial, and I want it with you, and I want it this spring," he told Sullivan, per CNN. Cruz wasn't ready to commit to anything. Outside court, he told reporters, "I'll be talking more on November 16."
What Vinnie has said about this case
“When we watched Lindsay Clancy's criminal case, there was a theme that came from Kevin Reddington and it was a theme that everyone talked about that Lindsay Clancy's doctors were horrific.”
Vinnie Politan on his show, “Patrick Clancy's Lawsuit Is Already in Trouble” (October 28, 2026)
“Lindsay Clancy loses again and loses in a big way inside of the courtroom and this is now becoming a routine here for Kevin Reddington.”
Vinnie Politan on his show, “Lindsay Clancy Loses Again” (October 26, 2026)
What happens next
Both sides are back in Plymouth Superior Court on November 16, 2026, to hash out scheduling for a second trial. Sullivan wants the retrial underway by March 2027. What prosecutors haven't said: whether they'll bring the same murder charges, go for something lesser like manslaughter, or try to cut a plea deal. They could also come back and ask for that gag order again, if Clancy's lawyers keep talking in a way prosecutors think could poison the jury pool.
How this plays in court
Whoever retries this case has to answer one question. Will the same evidence land differently with a new jury than it did with the last one? That panel came within one vote of acquittal. The 11-1 split toward not guilty is a signal the circumstantial case for criminal responsibility, as opposed to the underlying act, was not as strong as the state believed going in.
Expect the defense to run the same playbook: postpartum psychosis, built on the argument that severe mental illness left Clancy unable to grasp that what she was doing was wrong. That's the legal threshold — not just a diagnosis. Look for the same reliance on expert psychiatric testimony and Clancy's documented mental health decline after Callan was born.
Sullivan's denial closes off one route the defense had to attack the retrial itself — digging into the holdout juror. But it doesn't touch the real fight. A new jury will still have to decide whether Clancy's actions before and during the killings show deliberate planning, as prosecutors argue. Or whether they show a mind taken over by psychosis, as the defense contends.
A jury will also have to weigh something else. Is a reduced charge, like manslaughter, more realistic for prosecutors than retrying first-degree murder a second time? The defendant's conduct has never been in dispute — only her criminal responsibility for it.
- Boston 25 News: Judge Sides With Lindsay Clancy Again, Rejects Bid To Limit What Her Lawyers Can Say
- WWBT: Judge’s ruling could clear way for Lindsay Clancy to be tried again in deaths of her 3 kids
- Newsweek: Lindsay Clancy Update: Judge Denies Motion to Dismiss Child Murder Case
- The Guardian: Lindsay Clancy back in court seeking to dismiss murder charges after mistrial
- CNN: Lindsay Clancy’s judge eyes March 2027 for retrial – if there is one