JURY SCANDAL

Judge Orders Release Of Secret Jury-tampering Records That Blew Up Alex Murdaugh's Homicide Case

· How we report

A juror vanished from the box mid-trial. A court clerk is accused of working the jury from the inside. Now a South Carolina judge wants the sealed paper trail out in the open — because that paper trail is the reason Alex Murdaugh's double-murder convictions are gone.

Case at a glance

  • Alex Murdaugh — disbarred lawyer, convictions overturned, awaiting retrial decision, accused
  • Becky Hill — former Colleton County Clerk of Court, convicted
  • Debra R. McCaslin — South Carolina judge overseeing the records order, official

Next: Judge Debra McCaslin has promised a written ruling — expected the week of Nov. 23 — on whether to dismiss Murdaugh's original murder indictments over that disputed grand jury testimony. Meanwhile, the State has until Nov. 30 to finish redacting jurors' identities from the Juror 785 and Becky Hill investigation files before any of it can go public. Prosecutors can ask for more time. And a retrial on the murder charges is already being talked about, aimed at an April 5 target date, with or without a freshly obtained indictment.

Every report on the Alex Murdaugh case →

Judge Orders Release Of Secret Jury-tampering Records That Blew Up Alex Murdaugh's Homicide Case

A life sentence that fell apart

Maggie Murdaugh and her younger son, Paul, were shot to death in 2021 near the kennels on the family's sprawling Lowcountry property. Prosecutors charged Alex Murdaugh, once a prominent South Carolina attorney, with killing them both.

A jury convicted him in 2023. The judge sentenced him to life. Partway through that trial, she'd already pulled one juror off the case. The woman, identified in court papers only as Juror 785, had talked about it with people outside the jury room.

Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
Vinnie Uncensored: one free email every Sunday.

Investigators later turned their attention inward, to Colleton County's own Clerk of Court, Becky Hill. She's accused of improperly contacting jurors during the trial. In December 2025, Hill pleaded guilty to misconduct in office and perjury.

Then in May, the South Carolina Supreme Court tore up Murdaugh's murder convictions. The justices ruled Hill's comments to jurors had improperly swayed them. His life sentence for the killings went down with it — though he's still locked up on separate financial-crime convictions the murder case never touched.

On Nov. 13, Murdaugh's lawyers asked Judge McCaslin to throw out the original murder indictments altogether, arguing the lead SLED investigator misled the grand jury. She didn't rule that day. Four days later, on Nov. 17, she signed a different order instead. Release the sealed records on Juror 785's removal and the full Hill investigation, once jurors' identities and other sensitive material are blacked out.

Faces behind the sealed files

Alex Murdaugh, 58, used to be one of the best-known personal-injury lawyers in South Carolina's Lowcountry. He's already serving decades in prison for stealing millions of dollars from clients. In court, he's admitted to being a thief, an insurance cheat and a longtime opioid addict. He denies killing his wife and son.

Becky Hill ran the Colleton County Clerk of Court's office during the 2023 trial. She's accused of improperly contacting jurors, and in December 2025 she pleaded guilty to misconduct in office and perjury.

Juror 785 is the name the court record uses for the woman pulled off the jury mid-trial, after the judge found she'd discussed the case outside the jury room. Her real identity stays protected, and this coverage doesn't name her.

Judge Debra R. McCaslin signed the Nov. 17 order. She's also weighing the defense's separate motion to dismiss the original murder indictments. Prosecutor Creighton Waters and defense attorney Jim Griffin argued that motion in front of her on Nov. 13.

David Owen led the murder investigation for the South Carolina Law Enforcement Division and testified before the grand jury. The defense says he fed that grand jury false information about blood evidence and ammunition. He retired abruptly in 2024, not long after being named State Law Enforcement Officer of the Year. Former South Carolina Attorney General Charlie Condon has also weighed in publicly on the timing of the records' release.

"The blood from his murdered son sprang through the air — it's raining back on him — puts him there." — Jim Griffin, Alex Murdaugh's defense attorney, to CBS News

What the paperwork actually says

Murdaugh was charged with two counts of murder for killing his wife and son. A jury convicted him in 2023 and a judge sentenced him to life. That conviction and that sentence no longer stand — the state Supreme Court vacated both in May after finding Hill's contact with jurors had tainted the verdict. He hasn't been acquitted. He's back to square one: awaiting trial on the same two murder charges.

Hill's case went a different way. She pleaded guilty in December 2025 to misconduct in office and perjury. Misconduct in office covers a public official abusing the trust of their position; perjury means lying under oath. The coverage reviewed here doesn't include a sentence for Hill.

The Nov. 17 order from Judge McCaslin doesn't unseal a single page by itself. It just sets a deadline. The State has until Nov. 30 to redact jurors' identities and other sensitive material from the sealed transcripts. That covers Juror 785's file and the full Hill investigation — interview records, recordings, all of it — before any of it becomes public. The State can ask for more time, and the court noted the video and audio recordings alone could take extra work to redact.

Separately, at the Nov. 13 hearing, the defense asked McCaslin to dismiss the original murder indictments outright. Their argument: SLED agent David Owen told the grand jury that blood spatter was found on a T-shirt Murdaugh wore the night of the killings. That claim is contradicted by an earlier report that found no blood stains — evidence that was never introduced at trial. They also argued Owen told the grand jury that ammunition matching what killed Paul Murdaugh was found loaded in weapons across the property, which prosecutors say wasn't accurate. McCaslin didn't rule from the bench. She promised a written decision the following week. Even a dismissal wouldn't necessarily stop an April retrial, since prosecutors can seek a fresh indictment.

The fight that played out in court

Defense attorney Jim Griffin argued the disputed grand jury testimony about blood evidence was the only thing that put Murdaugh at the exact time and place of the killings. "A phone call doesn't put him there. The video doesn't put him there," Griffin said, according to CBS News. "The blood from his murdered son sprang through the air — it's raining back on him — puts him there."

Griffin wants the judge to scrap the case and start over. "What we're asking, your honor, is to reboot — go back to square one," he said, CBS News reported.

Prosecutor Creighton Waters pushed back. He told the court Owen's disputed statements reflected what the agent understood at the time, and didn't change the weight of everything else the grand jury heard. "This is what the agent understood at the time. And it's ultimately not something that would cause a substantial effect on the grand jury or cast grave doubt when we look at all the other evidence that was presented," Waters said, per CBS News. Prosecutors wrote in court filings that "a single mistake is not bad faith," according to CBS News.

McCaslin's own question at the hearing hinted at where this might be headed. She asked Waters: "If you had to go back to the grand jury, could you have it all done and ready to go by April 5th?" CBS News reported. Separately, former South Carolina Attorney General Charlie Condon told WPDE he supports releasing the jury-tampering records. But he questioned the timing — coming just months before Murdaugh is set to face a new trial.

Vinnie on air

What Vinnie has said about this case

“You'll remember in the Murdoch case, we had jurors who were interfered with by Becky Hill.”

Vinnie Politan on his show, “Kevin Reddington Attacks!” (September 29, 2026)

“Becky Hill did and then perhaps give him a little bit more of a benefit of a doubt.”

Vinnie Politan on his show, “Murdaugh Wins...Now What... the Tangent Podcast” (May 15, 2026)

What happens next

Judge Debra McCaslin has promised a written ruling — expected the week of Nov. 23 — on whether to dismiss Murdaugh's original murder indictments over that disputed grand jury testimony. Meanwhile, the State has until Nov. 30 to finish redacting jurors' identities from the Juror 785 and Becky Hill investigation files before any of it can go public. Prosecutors can ask for more time. And a retrial on the murder charges is already being talked about, aimed at an April 5 target date, with or without a freshly obtained indictment.

The legal read

How this plays in court

The appellate reversal in May turned entirely on Becky Hill's contact with jurors, not on the strength of the case against Murdaugh. That distinction matters: a retrial lets prosecutors put the same evidence in front of a jury that wasn't compromised, instead of starting from a weaker position.

The defense's push to dismiss the original indictments comes down to materiality. Were SLED agent David Owen's two disputed statements to the grand jury — the T-shirt blood and the loaded ammunition — enough to taint the indictment itself? Courts set that bar high, since grand juries routinely hear summarized or imperfect evidence as a matter of course. Prosecutors are leaning on that standard when they argue "a single mistake is not bad faith."

Even if McCaslin throws out the indictments, prosecutors can go back to a grand jury before April 5 and refile. The dismissal fight likely delays the case rather than ending it. The evidentiary fight that actually decides it stays the same. No DNA or blood was recovered on Murdaugh despite a close-range killing — a point the defense will keep pressing. Prosecutors, for their part, will keep leaning on the kennel video, the financial motive and the timeline.

Once the Juror 785 and Hill files are unsealed, the real question for anyone assessing the integrity of the 2023 verdict is scope. Did Hill's contact reach jurors who stayed through deliberations, or was it limited to the one juror removed before a verdict was reached? That distinction is legally significant, and right now, it's unanswered in the public record.

Sources. This report draws on the following coverage; quotes are reproduced as those outlets printed them.
  • ABC Columbia: Judge Orders Release Of Secret Jury-tampering Records That Blew Up Alex Murdaugh's Homicide Case
  • WPDE: Judge orders release of redacted records tied to Murdaugh jury investigations
  • CBS News: Alex Murdaugh lawyers say top investigator lied to grand jury, want murder indictments tossed
Vinnie Politan is a former prosecutor and veteran trial anchor.
Vinnie Uncensored · every Sunday
Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
One email every Sunday: the week's biggest cases, the real charges, nothing softened. Free. Unsubscribe anytime.