Attorney Warns Key Witness In Alex Murdaugh Case Could Implode Under Cross-examination
Alex Murdaugh's own lead investigator built the murder case against him. Now the man's lawyers say that investigator lied to the grand jury that indicted him — and an outside attorney says he's still the most dangerous man on the witness list.
Case at a glance
- Alex Murdaugh — defendant awaiting retrial for the deaths of his wife and son, accused
- David Owen — SLED agent who led the Murdaugh investigation
- Eric Bland — attorney and legal commentator
- Creighton Waters — prosecutor, official
- Debra McCaslin — judge overseeing the retrial motions, official
- Maggie Murdaugh — victim
Next: Judge Debra McCaslin has promised a written ruling on the dismissal motion within the week following the hearing. If she denies it, Murdaugh's April 2027 retrial proceeds on the existing indictments; if she grants it, prosecutors say they can seek new indictments as soon as next month without delaying that trial date.

The man who built the case is now the target
Maggie and Paul Murdaugh were shot to death in June 2021 at the family's sprawling property in the South Carolina Lowcountry. SLED Agent David Owen was the lead investigator. He sat down with Alex Murdaugh in a car at the scene around 10 p.m. that night, then again in August — that time with defense attorney Jim Griffin in the room.
Owen's work is what put Murdaugh under indictment for murder. A jury convicted him in 2023, and a judge sent him away for life. The South Carolina Supreme Court later tore that verdict up, ruling a court clerk had improperly influenced jurors during the trial. Now a retrial is set for April 2027.
This time, Murdaugh's lawyers aren't just fighting the trial. They want to unwind the indictment itself. They say Owen told the Colleton County grand jury two things that weren't true: that blood spatter turned up on the shirt Murdaugh wore the night of the killings, and that the same buckshot-and-birdshot mix used on Paul was found loaded in guns around the property. Neither claim holds up. Forensic testing never found human blood on that shirt, and no blood evidence like that ever reached the 2023 trial. The ammunition claim wasn't accurate either, according to court filings described by CBS News and the Associated Press.
Attorney Eric Bland isn't on either legal team, but he told NewsNation's Brian Entin that this fight follows Owen all the way to the retrial, no matter how the dismissal motion lands. "David Owen is going to be a problematic witness for the prosecution at this trial because he's going to be subject to this cross-examination," Bland said.
Who's involved
Alex Murdaugh, 58, was once one of South Carolina's most prominent attorneys. A jury convicted him in 2023 of murdering his wife, Maggie, and his younger son, Paul — a conviction that's since been vacated. He's also serving a lengthy separate sentence for stealing millions of dollars from clients and his own law firm, and has admitted in court to being a thief, an insurance cheat and a longtime opioid addict. He still denies killing his wife and son.
SLED Agent David Owen led the investigation that produced Murdaugh's murder indictments and his 2023 conviction. He retired abruptly in 2024, not long after being named South Carolina's Law Enforcement Officer of the Year. Now he sits at the center of the defense's push to wipe out the original indictments.
Prosecutor Creighton Waters is defending Owen's grand jury testimony and the case built on it. Defense attorney Jim Griffin is leading the charge to throw it out. Judge Debra McCaslin is weighing that motion while overseeing the April 2027 retrial already on the calendar. Attorney Eric Bland and criminal defense attorney Sam Bassett aren't part of the case — both offered outside analysis, to NewsNation and WTOC respectively.
"If I'm David Owen, between now and April, my stomach is going to get a little bit tight, because if he gets up on that witness stand, somebody's coming at him with sharp knives." — Eric Bland, to NewsNation
What a dismissal would and wouldn't change
Murdaugh hasn't been hit with anything new. He's still under the original 2021 murder indictments for killing Maggie and Paul, waiting on that April 2027 retrial after the state Supreme Court vacated his conviction and life sentence. His lawyers' motion asks Judge McCaslin to scrap those indictments completely and send the case back to a grand jury.
At the hearing, McCaslin didn't rule from the bench. She told both sides a written decision was coming the following week. At one point she turned to prosecutor Creighton Waters and asked whether the state could take the case to a new grand jury and still be ready "by April 5th" if she tossed the existing indictments — a question CBS News and the Associated Press both flagged as a possible tell on where she's leaning.
Even if the defense wins this round, the case doesn't end. Prosecutors say they can seek new indictments as soon as next month, and defense attorneys told the court they won't try to block that. None of this touches Murdaugh's time behind bars on the unrelated financial crimes — those sentences keep running no matter how the murder case shakes out.
The other case that haunts the investigator
Owen's résumé outside the Murdaugh case has become part of the argument against him. He retired abruptly in 2024, not long after being honored as South Carolina's Law Enforcement Officer of the Year.
In a different murder case Owen investigated, a judge threw out the conviction last year. The reason: the victim's mother said she'd told Owen her daughter threatened to take her own life days before she died, and Owen never passed that along to prosecutors or the defense. CBS News reported the young woman was found dead by the same method she'd told her mother she planned to use.
Prosecutors in the Murdaugh case push back hard on the comparison. They point out that everything in dispute now — the shirt testing, the ammunition — was information the defense already had at the 2023 trial. That's not the same, they argue, as evidence withheld entirely, like what happened in Owen's other case.
What each side has said
Prosecutor Creighton Waters told the court Owen's grand jury testimony about the ammunition was a mistake, not a lie. "This was not overtly false. This was what the agent understood at the time," he said, according to NewsNation. On the broader testimony, he argued the outcome wouldn't have changed: "This is what the agent understood at the time. And it's ultimately not something that would cause a substantial effect on the grand jury or cast grave doubt when we look at all the other evidence that was presented," Waters said, per CBS News.
Defense attorney Jim Griffin sees it differently. He argued the blood evidence was the only testimony that put Murdaugh at the scene at the time of the killings. "A phone call doesn't put him there. The video doesn't put him there," Griffin told the court, according to CBS News. "The blood from his murdered son sprang through the air — it's raining back on him — puts him there." He asked the judge to "reboot — go back to square one."
Eric Bland, watching from outside the case, doesn't expect the dismissal motion to succeed. But he says it lays groundwork the defense will use at trial — including Owen's own admission from the first trial that he had "testified falsely to a grand jury," per NewsNation. "He's a very, very important witness," Bland said. "I'm not sure they're going to be able to present the case without him." Then he added: "If I'm David Owen, between now and April, my stomach is going to get a little bit tight, because if he gets up on that witness stand, somebody's coming at him with sharp knives."
Criminal defense attorney Sam Bassett, offering outside analysis to WTOC, says the judge is facing a high bar here. "Did this affect the outcome of the grand jury proceeding? If this information had not been presented, can they make an argument that an indictment would not have occurred?" Bassett said. "So, there is another level of analysis that the courts are going to have to do as well."
What happens next
Judge Debra McCaslin has promised a written ruling on the dismissal motion within the week following the hearing. If she denies it, Murdaugh's April 2027 retrial proceeds on the existing indictments; if she grants it, prosecutors say they can seek new indictments as soon as next month without delaying that trial date.
How this plays in court
A prosecutor reviewing this record would focus on materiality: whether the disputed testimony about blood spatter and ammunition actually changed the grand jury's probable-cause finding, or was cumulative alongside the kennel video, the family's debts and the collapsing financial schemes also presented.
The defense will argue the false testimony was not incidental — Jim Griffin has already told the court the blood evidence was the only testimony placing Murdaugh at the kennels at the time of the killings, which would make it outcome-determinative rather than a harmless mistake.
If the case reaches trial, jurors will have to weigh David Owen's credibility on cross-examination, including his own acknowledged false testimony to the first grand jury and the unrelated case a judge threw out over information he failed to pass along — without treating either as proof he lied this time.
Judge McCaslin's question about whether prosecutors could re-present the case to a new grand jury and still meet an April 5 deadline suggests the court is weighing practical trial-schedule consequences alongside the legal merits of dismissal.
- NewsNation: Attorney Warns Key Witness In Alex Murdaugh Case Could Implode Under Cross-examination
- ABC News - Breaking News, Latest News and Videos: Alex Murdaugh wants murder indictments dismissed, saying agent lied to grand jury
- WTOC: Alex Murdaugh’s defense seeks case dismissal, alleging mishandled evidence and misleading grand jury testimony
- CBS News: Alex Murdaugh lawyers say top investigator lied to grand jury, want murder indictments tossed