SOUTH CAROLINA CIRCUIT

Murdaugh's Lawyers Say Lead Agent Lied To Grand Jury

· How we report

Alex Murdaugh says he found his wife and son dead by the dog kennels at Moselle, wearing a white T-shirt at the time. Now his lawyers want the murder indictments that followed thrown out. They argue the lead SLED agent told a grand jury in 2022 that blood spatter on that shirt placed Murdaugh at the killings. That claim came months after the state lab found no human blood on the shirt at all. A written ruling is due next week.

Case at a glance

  • Alex Murdaugh — subject

Next: Judge McCaslin didn't rule from the bench at the Nov. 13 hearing in Lexington County. She said a written decision would come next week. From there, the case moves to Sumter County for another pretrial hearing on Jan. 20. Murdaugh's retrial on the underlying murder charges stays on the calendar for April 5, no matter how McCaslin rules on the indictments.

Every report on the Alex Murdaugh case →

Murdaugh's Lawyers Say Lead Agent Lied To Grand Jury

The shirt that became the case

Maggie Murdaugh and her son Paul died on the family's hunting property in Colleton County, South Carolina, on June 7, 2021. Alex Murdaugh told investigators he found them by the dog kennels. He said he was wearing a white T-shirt at the time.

The state crime lab tested that shirt in August 2021. It found no human blood on it at all, according to the defense's account of the lab's own report. A state forensic expert agreed at first: no spatter on the shirt. Then the expert reversed course. A final report, dated March 29, 2022, said more than 100 stains on the shirt were consistent with spatter.

Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
Vinnie Uncensored: one free email every Sunday.

That spatter finding hit the press in April 2022. By July, it was in front of a Colleton County grand jury. The grand jury indicted Murdaugh. A jury convicted him in 2023 of murdering his wife and son. He was sentenced to life in prison.

The South Carolina Supreme Court threw that conviction out in May 2026. The court found a clerk had improperly influenced jurors during the trial, and it ordered a new one. On Nov. 13, 2026, at a pretrial hearing in Lexington County, Murdaugh's attorneys filed a 33-page motion. They're asking Judge Debra McCaslin to dismiss the four original indictments outright, arguing the lead investigator lied to the grand jury that indicted him.

The names that matter here

Alex Murdaugh, 58, is the disgraced Lowcountry lawyer at the center of it all. He's already serving decades in prison for stealing millions from his own legal clients. In court, he's admitted to being "a thief, insurance cheat, bad lawyer and longtime opioid addict," according to the Los Angeles Times. He denies killing his wife and son.

Maggie Murdaugh and Paul Murdaugh are the victims. She was his wife, he was their younger son. Both were killed at the family's Moselle property in 2021.

David Owen led the murder investigation for the State Law Enforcement Division. He's the one who testified to the grand jury that indicted Murdaugh. He retired abruptly in 2024 -- not long after being named the state's law enforcement officer of the year.

Jim Griffin and Dick Harpootlian are defending Murdaugh. Creighton Waters is the lead prosecutor. Judge Debra McCaslin is presiding over the pretrial fight. Sam Bassett, a criminal defense attorney with no stake in the case, offered outside legal analysis to WTOC.

"The blood from his murdered son sprang through the air -- it's raining back on him -- puts him there." — Jim Griffin, Alex Murdaugh's defense attorney, to the Los Angeles Times

The claim at the heart of the motion

The defense's motion, filed Nov. 13, asks McCaslin to dismiss all four indictments against Murdaugh without prejudice. That's a technical distinction with real teeth: it would send the case back to a new grand jury instead of ending it outright. The defense says it wants a fresh grand jury to look at the case without pushing back the trial, which is still set for April 5.

The motion's central claim is blunt. Investigators testified "that an expert had found the victims' blood spatter on the shirt Mr. Murdaugh was wearing when he found the bodies of his wife and son, even though the State's laboratory had confirmed, eleven months before the agent testified, that there was no human blood on the shirt," according to South Carolina Public Radio's account of the filing.

The defense points to a second claim too. It says Owen told the grand jury that shotguns loaded with the same buckshot-and-birdshot combination used to kill Paul turned up all over the Murdaugh property. The defense says that wasn't true -- no gun at Moselle was loaded like the murder weapons. Owen himself admitted at the 2023 trial that his grand jury testimony was "not accurate" and that he had used "trickery."

Prosecutors don't deny the errors happened. They argue the errors fall short of the bad-faith standard the law requires to throw out an indictment, writing in court papers that "a single mistake is not bad faith." And they've made clear that if McCaslin sides with the defense, they can go get new indictments -- potentially within weeks -- in time for the April retrial.

The other case that haunts Owen

Owen's credibility was already shaky before this motion. A judge threw out a different murder case he worked last year. The judge found Owen never told prosecutors or the defense that the victim's mother had warned him her daughter made a suicide threat days before she died. The woman was found dead by the exact method she'd described to her mother.

That case has nothing to do with the Murdaugh prosecution directly. But the defense keeps bringing it up, arguing it shows a pattern: Owen withholding or misrepresenting what investigators actually knew when he testified.

The fight in Judge McCaslin's courtroom

Griffin didn't treat the blood-spatter testimony like some minor detail. He called it the only evidence that placed Murdaugh at the exact time and place of the killings. "A phone call doesn't put him there. The video doesn't put him there," Griffin said, according to the Los Angeles Times. "The blood from his murdered son sprang through the air -- it's raining back on him -- puts him there."

Griffin put it simply to the court: "What we're asking, your honor, is to reboot — go back to square one," the Los Angeles Times reported.

Prosecutor Creighton Waters pushed back, defending Owen's testimony as a good-faith account of what the agent believed at the time. "This is what the agent understood at the time. And it's ultimately not something that would cause a substantial effect on the grand jury or cast grave doubt when we look at all the other evidence that was presented," Waters said, per the Los Angeles Times.

Judge McCaslin gave no sign of which way she was leaning. But she asked Waters a pointed question directly: "If you had to go back to the grand jury, could you have it all done and ready to go by April 5th?" the Los Angeles Times reported. Defense attorneys and legal analysts read that question as a signal of where she may be headed.

Outside analyst Sam Bassett told WTOC the court is facing a genuinely hard legal question. "Did this affect the outcome of the grand jury proceeding? If this information had not been presented, can they make an argument that an indictment would not have occurred? ... So, there is another level of analysis that the courts are going to have to do as well," he said.

What happens next

Judge McCaslin didn't rule from the bench at the Nov. 13 hearing in Lexington County. She said a written decision would come next week. From there, the case moves to Sumter County for another pretrial hearing on Jan. 20. Murdaugh's retrial on the underlying murder charges stays on the calendar for April 5, no matter how McCaslin rules on the indictments.

The legal read

How this plays in court

Courts only dismiss an indictment for prosecutorial misconduct on a showing of bad faith, not mere error. That's why prosecutors are leaning on the "a single mistake is not bad faith" framing instead of defending the substance of Owen's grand jury testimony.

The defense will argue the blood-spatter claim wasn't some stray detail. By Griffin's account, it was the only piece of grand jury evidence placing Murdaugh at the kennels at the time of the killings. The recorded video and other evidence establish presence, but not that critical window of time.

Prosecutors will point to everything else the grand jury saw: the kennel recording, missing guns matching possible murder weapons, mounting family debts, and an imminent discovery of Murdaugh's thefts. Their argument is that the case for indictment holds even if Owen's spatter testimony gets set aside.

Even a defense win here may prove largely symbolic. Prosecutors have said they can seek a new indictment on an accelerated timeline. And the judge's own question to Waters about meeting an April 5 deadline suggests she's already weighing how a re-indictment would fit the retrial schedule.

Sources. This report draws on the following coverage; quotes are reproduced as those outlets printed them.
  • South Carolina Public Radio: Murdaugh's lawyers ask for double-murder charges to be thrown out
  • Los Angeles Times: Alex Murdaugh wants murder indictments dismissed, saying agent lied to grand jury
  • WRDW: Murdaugh seeks dismissal of murder indictments over disputed evidence
  • WTOC: Alex Murdaugh’s defense seeks case dismissal, alleging mishandled evidence and misleading grand jury testimony
Vinnie Politan is a former prosecutor and veteran trial anchor.
Vinnie Uncensored · every Sunday
Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
One email every Sunday: the week's biggest cases, the real charges, nothing softened. Free. Unsubscribe anytime.