Lindsay Clancy Asks Massachusetts' Highest Court To Spare Her A Retrial For Killing Her 3 Kids
Lindsay Clancy wants a single justice of the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court to throw out her murder case before she faces a jury again. She's arguing a second trial would violate her right against double jeopardy. Jury selection for that retrial is set for March 29.
Case at a glance
- Lindsay Clancy — defendant, Duxbury mother, accused
- Cora Clancy — victim, age 5, victim
- Dawson Clancy — victim, age 3, victim
- Callan Clancy — victim, age 8 months, victim
- Michael Desronvil — holdout juror in first trial
- William Sullivan — Plymouth Superior Court Judge, official
Next: Justice Elizabeth N. Dewar, a single justice on the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, is deciding whether to hear oral arguments on Clancy's double-jeopardy petition and send it to the full court. If nothing stops the case first, jury selection for Clancy's retrial on first-degree murder charges begins March 29, before Judge William Sullivan in Plymouth Superior Court.

The basement in Duxbury, January 24, 2023
Cora was 5. Dawson was 3. Callan was 8 months old. On January 24, 2023, Lindsay Clancy strangled all three of her children with exercise bands, in the basement of the family's Duxbury, Massachusetts home.
Then she turned the knife on herself, and jumped from a second-story window, trying to end her own life. The fall paralyzed her. She sat in a wheelchair throughout her trial, and she's remained in state psychiatric custody since 2023, most recently at Tewksbury Hospital.
Nobody in that first trial argued she didn't do it. The only question was whether the law should hold her responsible for it.
Seven weeks, one deadlocked jury
Three children. Three counts of first-degree murder, one for each. The trial ran roughly seven weeks and pulled in heavy public attention, including a courthouse livestream that thousands of people watched.
Her attorney, Kevin Reddington, argued she was suffering from postpartum psychosis at the time. He said she should be found not criminally responsible, what Massachusetts law calls lack of criminal responsibility and what's known elsewhere as an insanity defense. Prosecutors, led by Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague under Plymouth County District Attorney Timothy Cruz, argued Clancy was mentally capable of a premeditated act.
On September 4, after seven days of deliberation, a jury of nine women and three men told Judge William Sullivan they were deadlocked. He declared a mistrial. Jurors later said 11 of the 12 were ready to find Clancy not guilty by reason of insanity. That verdict would have sent her to a state psychiatric hospital, under ongoing court review. One juror, identified in later reporting as Michael Desronvil, wouldn't go along.
The fight over a single holdout juror
Clancy's defense moved to dismiss the case outright. A retrial, they argued, would violate double jeopardy, the constitutional protection against being tried twice for the same crime. Sullivan, they said, should have questioned the holdout juror and potentially removed him, instead of declaring a mistrial. Jury notes, they pointed out, showed the juror wasn't following instructions on reasonable doubt.
Judge Sullivan said no. Digging into the holdout's reasoning, he ruled, would mean improperly probing the jury's deliberative process. In his written order, he put it this way: "this Court concludes that any further judicial inquiry is inappropriate, given the mandate that the court must not delve into a juror's subjective reasoning, thought process, view of the case, or relationship to the other jurors, and must not inquire into the jury's deliberative content, collective thought process, or any disagreement among the jury." It wasn't his first no. Sullivan had already turned down a defense request to swap the holdout for an alternate mid-deliberation. He later rejected a bid for an evidentiary hearing into whether that juror had lied on his questionnaire or used his phone during deliberations, finding none of it relevant to whether a mistrial was necessary.
With that motion dead, Sullivan set a date: jury selection for the retrial begins March 29. At a November 16 hearing, prosecutor Jennifer Sprague told the court the charges "require a jury trial." She didn't specify which charges the DA's office will pursue, though she never changed them from first-degree murder.
Now Clancy's defense has taken the fight higher, to the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court. Their petition asks a single justice to hold oral arguments and send the double-jeopardy question to the full court. Justice Elizabeth N. Dewar has it under advisement. A single justice of the SJC had already declined to step in once before, at an earlier stage of the case.
In their own words
In their SJC petition, Clancy's lawyers put it bluntly: she "should not be 'forced to run the gantlet' again," they wrote. They went further: "Ms. Clancy has lived under the significant strain of this case, often accompanied by frenzied media attention, for more than three years. She proceeded to trial, at which her guilt or innocence was vigorously contested over the course of approximately seven weeks. At the end of that ordeal, 11 jurors believed that the Commonwealth had not satisfied its burden to prove her guilt beyond a reasonable doubt."
On that holdout juror, the defense didn't hedge. "There is a substantial possibility that the trial court, after inquiry, would have discharged the non-compliant juror. Such possibility, therefore, constitutes a viable alternative to the mistrial, precluding a finding of manifest necessity," the petition reads, according to Boston.com.
At the November hearing, defense attorney Kevin Reddington said he's sure of what's coming: another first-degree murder case. "The die has been cast," he told the court, per WBUR. "When they say the case is going to require a jury, it's an indirect comment they intend to proceed on first-degree murder indictments."
Back during the first trial, Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague wasn't having the mental-health framing. In her closing argument, according to NPR, she told jurors: "This case is not about our mental health system or how it treats women. That's a distraction to get you angry and passionate about an important issue, but an issue that's not on trial here."
What Vinnie has said about this case
“When we watched Lindsay Clancy's criminal case, there was a theme that came from Kevin Reddington and it was a theme that everyone talked about that Lindsay Clancy's doctors were horrific.”
Vinnie Politan on his show, “Patrick Clancy's Lawsuit Is Already in Trouble” (October 28, 2026)
“Lindsay Clancy loses again and loses in a big way inside of the courtroom and this is now becoming a routine here for Kevin Reddington.”
Vinnie Politan on his show, “Lindsay Clancy Loses Again” (October 26, 2026)
What happens next
Justice Elizabeth N. Dewar, a single justice on the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, is deciding whether to hear oral arguments on Clancy's double-jeopardy petition and send it to the full court. If nothing stops the case first, jury selection for Clancy's retrial on first-degree murder charges begins March 29, before Judge William Sullivan in Plymouth Superior Court.
How this plays in court
The core legal question for the SJC is narrow. Did Judge Sullivan's decision to declare a mistrial, rather than investigate or remove the holdout juror, amount to "manifest necessity"? That's the standard that must be met before a second trial avoids violating double jeopardy. Appellate courts generally give trial judges wide latitude on that call, precisely because judges aren't supposed to probe why a juror voted the way they did.
The defense's strongest argument is that Sullivan had a viable alternative: investigating and potentially discharging the holdout. He skipped it. The prosecution's counter, which Sullivan adopted in his written ruling, is that doing so would have forced the judge to wade into the jury's actual deliberations and reasoning. The law generally forbids that, regardless of how the vote split.
If the SJC declines to intervene, the retrial runs on the same theory as the first one: did Clancy have the mental capacity to be held criminally responsible, or does postpartum psychosis meet Massachusetts' standard for lack of criminal responsibility? The fact that the first jury split 11-1 toward acquittal by reason of insanity won't be admissible at the retrial. That means both sides will present largely the same evidence to a new jury with no memory of how the first trial came out.
A first-degree murder conviction in Massachusetts carries a mandatory sentence of life without parole. A verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity, by contrast, would commit Clancy to a state psychiatric hospital, subject to ongoing court review — the outcome her defense says 11 of 12 jurors were prepared to reach.
- Boston.com: Lindsay Clancy Asks Massachusetts' Highest Court To Spare Her A Retrial For Killing Her 3 Kids
- NPR: Lindsay Clancy to face a new trial in spring of 2027 over children’s killing
- ABC News - Breaking News, Latest News and Videos: Lindsay Clancy murder trial: Judge denies request to question holdout juror
- The Guardian: Judge clears way for Lindsay Clancy to be retried on murder charges
- WBUR: Judge sets March date for Lindsay Clancy to face new trial