SENTENCED

Jury Rejects Insanity Defense, Judge Sentences Rodney Hinton Jr. To 15 Years To Life For Deputy's Death

· How we report

One day after Rodney Hinton Jr. watched the video of his own son's fatal shooting by Cincinnati police, a Hamilton County jury found him guilty of murder for running down Deputy Larry Henderson. On Monday, a judge sentenced him to 15 years to life and turned down his bid for a new trial.

Case at a glance

  • Rodney Hinton Jr. — defendant, sentenced for deputy's death, sentenced
  • Larry Henderson — Hamilton County Sheriff's Deputy killed May 2, 2025, victim
  • Jody M. Luebbers — Hamilton County Judge, official
  • Clyde Bennett — Defense attorney for Rodney Hinton Jr.
  • Lori Henderson — Deputy Henderson's wife, victim
  • Adrianna Henderson — Deputy Henderson's youngest daughter

Next: Clyde Bennett II says he'll file a formal appeal within 30 days of Monday's sentencing, pointing to trial errors including the alleged juror misconduct over Hinton's statements to his psychologist. Separately, the Larry Henderson Act, a bill named for the slain deputy, has cleared the Ohio House and remains pending in the state Senate.

Jury Rejects Insanity Defense, Judge Sentences Rodney Hinton Jr. To 15 Years To Life For Deputy's Death

A father watched the video, then drove

Ryan Hinton was 18 years old on May 1, 2025, when Cincinnati police officers shot and killed him. Hamilton County Prosecutor Connie Pillich later ruled the shooting justified.

The next day, Ryan's father walked into Cincinnati police headquarters and sat down to watch the body camera footage of his son's death. That's what Cincinnati Police Det. Carl Beebe testified at Rodney Hinton Jr.'s arraignment.

Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
Vinnie Uncensored: one free email every Sunday.

Hours later, prosecutors said, Hinton got in his car and drove toward the University of Cincinnati. Deputy Larry Henderson was there, directing graduation traffic at Martin Luther King Drive and Burnet Woods Drive. He'd spent more than three decades with the Hamilton County Sheriff's Office. Hinton's car crossed into oncoming lanes and hit him. Henderson died. He had no connection to Ryan Hinton's death at all. Police arrested Hinton that same day and charged him with murder.

Prosecutors told jurors the crash was no accident. According to FOX19, a prosecutor put it this way at trial: "As Deputy Henderson moved to the defendant's left, the vehicle moved to the left. The timing is impeccable,"

The people this case is about

Rodney Hinton Jr. was behind the wheel. He's the Cincinnati man whose son, Ryan Hinton, died at 18 when Cincinnati police shot him on May 1, 2025, in a shooting prosecutors ruled justified.

Larry Henderson gave more than 30 years to the Hamilton County Sheriff's Office. He was out directing graduation traffic the day he was killed. Sheriff Charmaine McGuffey told WCPO he was a fixture of the department: "He was a trainer. He was a bomb tech. He was a deputy. He was a mentor,"

He left behind his wife, Lori, and daughters Adrianna and Alexandria. All three addressed the court at sentencing.

Hamilton County Judge Jody M. Luebbers ran the trial and handed down Monday's sentence. Defense attorney Clyde Bennett II argued his client should be found not guilty by reason of insanity.

"I ask the court to hold the man — who in his own words said, 'I had to turn the wheel to hit him' — accountable." — Lori Henderson, Deputy Henderson's wife, to FOX19

Inside the jury's split verdict

Prosecutors indicted Hinton on multiple counts. The top charge was aggravated murder, Ohio's most serious homicide charge. It requires proof of a calculated, premeditated killing. They also charged him with murder and two counts of felonious assault.

The trial ran nearly two weeks. Jurors heard eyewitness accounts, crash-reconstruction analysis and video evidence from the state. The defense countered with testimony from Hinton's relatives and a mental health expert, who described years of psychiatric symptoms and treatment.

Jurors deliberated for more than two days, WCPO reported; WLWT put it at three days. WCPO reported the verdict came down Oct. 20. FOX19 and WLWT both reported Oct. 23.

The jury stopped short of aggravated murder. On what WCPO described as the two most serious counts, they came back instead with the lesser verdict of reckless homicide. But they convicted him outright of murder and both felonious assault counts.

Jurors rejected the insanity defense too. Bennett never disputed that Hinton's car struck and killed Henderson. His argument was that severe mental illness, layered on top of losing his son a day earlier, left Hinton unable to understand what he was doing was wrong. The jury found him criminally responsible anyway.

Fifteen years to life, and more

On Monday, Nov. 16, Judge Luebbers sentenced Hinton to 15 years to life in prison. He gets credit for the 563 days he's already spent in jail.

That sentence runs consecutively, not concurrently, with an 18-month term Hinton is already serving out of Clermont County for assaulting jail officers while in custody. In practice, he serves the Clermont County time on top of the homicide sentence, not alongside it.

Before sentencing, the judge denied two defense motions, one seeking a new trial over alleged juror misconduct and a related motion for acquittal. She told the courtroom she'd gone over the jury instructions with counsel "at least four times" and found no evidence jurors had been exposed to improper outside information.

Before she handed down the sentence, Luebbers spoke directly to Hinton. According to FOX19, she told him: "Mr. Hinton, I'm sorry for the loss of your son. I am. I can't imagine anything worse than losing your kid. I'm a parent too," before adding, "In this case, the jury has found you guilty of murder of Deputy Larry Henderson. You don't have the right to kill anybody, and the jury has spoken."

Grief, fury, and a lawyer who isn't done

Lori Henderson stood before the court and described more than a year of grief. "The day he was stolen from us, a part of me died as well... My rock, my everything was taken," she said, according to FOX19. Then she handed Hinton's own words back to him and asked the judge to hold him accountable: "I ask the court to hold the man — who in his own words said, 'I had to turn the wheel to hit him' — accountable."

Henderson's youngest daughter, Adrianna, read her own statement, then read a letter from her older sister, Alexandria, who couldn't attend. Alexandria wrote about the financial strain of losing her father and the milestones her own children will miss. Adrianna told the court: "My father was innocent, and he had absolutely no involvement with the loss of Ryan Hinton," before adding, "An eye for an eye makes the whole world blind. Murder is murder."

Defense attorney Clyde Bennett II held the line through trial: Hinton was in the grip of a psychotic episode. "The evidence indicates that that man was psychotic and experiencing acute psychotic symptoms from the time he left the parking lot," he told the court, according to FOX19. After the conviction, he told WCPO he wasn't walking away: "When I was hired by the Hinton family, I looked at Mr. Hinton. I looked him in his face, and I looked him in his eyes, and I told him I was going to fight for him. I'm not done."

The appeal that's already filed

Before sentencing, Bennett filed a motion for a new trial. His argument: jurors improperly considered statements Hinton made to his psychologist, testimony the judge had specifically told them not to use when deciding guilt. Bennett called that "extraneous prejudicial information" barred under Ohio evidence rules and asked the court to vacate the conviction.

He also wanted to subpoena jurors, under seal, and question them about how they'd used that evidence. Judge Luebbers denied both requests at sentencing. She found no evidence the jury had been exposed to anything improper.

Bennett says he'll file a formal appeal within 30 days of sentencing.

Separately, Ohio lawmakers have moved a bill named for the deputy, the Larry Henderson Act, through the state House. It's now pending before the state Senate, according to WCPO.

What happens next

Clyde Bennett II says he'll file a formal appeal within 30 days of Monday's sentencing, pointing to trial errors including the alleged juror misconduct over Hinton's statements to his psychologist. Separately, the Larry Henderson Act, a bill named for the slain deputy, has cleared the Ohio House and remains pending in the state Senate.

The legal read

How this plays in court

The split verdict — reckless homicide instead of aggravated murder on the two most serious counts, but murder on another — shows jurors accepted that Hinton intended to hit Henderson while stopping short of finding the calculated, premeditated plan Ohio's top charge requires.

Rejecting the insanity defense required jurors to conclude Hinton understood right from wrong at the moment he turned the wheel, despite defense evidence of psychiatric treatment and an alleged psychotic episode; the state's crash-reconstruction evidence and timing argument appear to have outweighed the defense's expert testimony.

The appeal will likely turn on the juror-misconduct claim — whether jurors improperly weighed Hinton's statements to his psychologist after being instructed not to use them on guilt. Appellate courts generally give heavy deference to a trial judge's own account of her jury instructions and the record, which could make that a difficult argument to win.

Running the homicide sentence consecutively to the Clermont County assault term shows the court treated the in-custody assault on jail officers as a separate aggravating factor at sentencing, not something folded into the homicide case.

Sources. This report draws on the following coverage; quotes are reproduced as those outlets printed them.
  • WCPO 9 News: Jury Rejects Insanity Defense, Judge Sentences Rodney Hinton Jr. To 15 Years To Life For Deputy's Death
  • WLWT: Attorney for Rodney Hinton Jr. files motion to subpoena jury members after murder conviction
  • FOX19 | Cincinnati: Cincinnati man found guilty of killing deputy to be sentenced as defense tries to appeal verdict
  • WLWT: Attorney for Rodney Hinton Jr. files motion for new trial after murder conviction
  • WVXU: Rodney Hinton Jr. sentenced for murder in deputy's death
Vinnie Politan is a former prosecutor and veteran trial anchor.
Vinnie Uncensored · every Sunday
Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
One email every Sunday: the week's biggest cases, the real charges, nothing softened. Free. Unsubscribe anytime.