LAWSUIT

Man Sues Kid Rock's Nashville Bar, Claims Security Guards Beat Him Up

· How we report

A Nashville bar patron says the security guards hired to protect customers at Kid Rock's honky tonk turned on him instead, and now he's suing the venue over how he was removed.

Case at a glance

  • Joshua Welch — Plaintiff who claims he was beaten by the bar's security guards, victim
  • Kid Rock — Owner of the Nashville bar named in the lawsuit, accused

Next: No hearing date, trial date or deadline shows up in the coverage reviewed. Ordinarily, the next concrete step would be the bar's formal response to Welch's complaint. But neither Taste of Country's report nor the underlying TMZ story says one exists yet, and the bar hadn't commented publicly as of that reporting.

Man Sues Kid Rock's Nashville Bar, Claims Security Guards Beat Him Up

A guitar, a bouncer, and a lawsuit

Joshua Welch walked into Kid Rock's Big A** Honky Tonk Rock N' Roll Steakhouse for a night out. He left with an injured finger and a lawsuit. The trouble, Taste of Country reports — citing TMZ's reporting on the case — started with something almost nothing: Welch touched a performer's guitar.

His own lawyer doesn't dress it up. The attorney told TMZ the touch was "a moment of poor judgment" — not a crime, just a lapse. Bar security noticed and moved to remove Welch from the building. That part, on its own, is a standard and legal thing for a bouncer to do.

Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
Vinnie Uncensored: one free email every Sunday.

Then, the lawsuit says, before security could walk him out, Welch touched the guitar again. What happened next wasn't a simple escort to the sidewalk. Welch says the guards used force far beyond anything a bouncer is allowed to use on a paying customer, and he walked away with an injured finger.

Nobody pins down exactly when any of this happened. Taste of Country's report and the TMZ story it cites don't give a date for the incident or for when Welch filed suit. Those details simply aren't part of the record reviewed for this story.

Who's named in the case

Joshua Welch is the one who filed suit. The coverage calls him a patron and nothing more — no age, no hometown.

The defendant is the bar itself: Kid Rock's Big A** Honky Tonk Rock N' Roll Steakhouse, the place the musician opened in downtown Nashville back in October 2018.

The guards who grabbed Welch don't get names in the reporting. Welch's suit accuses them — and the business that put them on the floor — of going well past what the law lets a bouncer do to a customer.

Kid Rock himself isn't named personally as a defendant anywhere in the coverage reviewed. This suit is aimed at the business, not the man behind it.

"a moment of poor judgment" — Joshua Welch's attorney, to TMZ, as cited by Taste of Country

The claims in the complaint

Four separate claims make up Welch's lawsuit, according to TMZ's reporting as relayed by Taste of Country: assault and battery, negligence, negligent hiring and training, and false imprisonment.

The assault and battery claim is the physical one. It alleges the guards made harmful, unwanted contact that went beyond any force reasonably needed to get a customer out the door.

The negligence and negligent hiring and training claims aim higher, at the bar itself. They allege the business failed to properly screen, train or supervise the men it hired for security. If Welch can prove that, the bar could be liable even if a jury decides the guards acted on their own.

Then there's false imprisonment: Welch says he was held against his will, longer than it took to get him out the door. No court, no docket number, no damages figure appears anywhere in the sourcing reviewed for this story.

What each side has said

Only one quote shows up anywhere in the coverage, and it comes from Welch's own side. His attorney told TMZ the guitar-touching was "a moment of poor judgment" — an admission, from Welch's own camp, that the night didn't start with him blameless.

Taste of Country says it reached out to Kid Rock's Big A** Honky Tonk Rock N' Roll Steakhouse for comment on the lawsuit. Silence. As of that report, the bar hadn't responded.

Kid Rock hasn't said a word about the suit anywhere in the coverage reviewed for this story.

A bar that's been in legal fights before

This isn't the Honky Tonk Steakhouse's first time in a courtroom fight. Back in 2020, Taste of Country reports, the bar joined a lawsuit against the city of Nashville and the state of Tennessee. The goal: recover revenue it lost during COVID-19 stay-at-home orders.

That suit came after the Tennessean reported that four Nashville bars — Kid Rock's among them — had their beer permits suspended for violating pandemic reopening rules.

Kid Rock opened the downtown Nashville bar in October 2018. He's also tied to a separate upscale Nashville restaurant, The Detroit Cowboy — an established part of his business footprint in the city long before this suit.

What happens next

No hearing date, trial date or deadline shows up in the coverage reviewed. Ordinarily, the next concrete step would be the bar's formal response to Welch's complaint. But neither Taste of Country's report nor the underlying TMZ story says one exists yet, and the bar hadn't commented publicly as of that reporting.

The legal read

How this plays in court

This is a civil suit, not a criminal case. That means Welch's side only has to show it's more likely than not — not proof beyond a reasonable doubt — that the guards used unreasonable force.

Expect the defense to argue the force was a proportionate response to a customer who touched the performer's equipment a second time after already being warned once. Call it a provocation-and-reasonable-force argument.

The negligent hiring and training claim is the one most likely to survive even if a jury clears the individual guards. It only requires showing the bar's screening or supervision of its security staff fell short of a reasonable standard.

A jury weighing this case will likely zero in on one gap. On one side: the alleged provocation, touching a guitar twice. On the other: the alleged response, an injury serious enough to prompt a lawsuit. That gap is what decides whether the force used was proportionate.

Sources. This report draws on the following coverage; quotes are reproduced as those outlets printed them.
  • Taste of Country: REPORT: Kid Rock's Bar Sued, Patron Says Security Brutally Beat Him + Injured His Finger
Vinnie Politan is a former prosecutor and veteran trial anchor.
Vinnie Uncensored · every Sunday
Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
One email every Sunday: the week's biggest cases, the real charges, nothing softened. Free. Unsubscribe anytime.