Wisconsin Prison

Family Killer Chris Watts Reportedly Has Relationships With Men In Prison

· How we report

Chris Watts is serving five life sentences for killing his pregnant wife and two daughters. Now an unnamed Dodge Correctional Institution employee says he's taken up with younger male inmates behind bars. The claim is anonymous and unverified.

Case at a glance

  • Chris Watts — serving life for killing his pregnant wife and daughters, convicted

Next: There's no court date coming out of any of this. Watts is already serving five consecutive life sentences with no parole, full stop. What's still open: whether the Wisconsin Department of Corrections ever puts anything on the record. Whether any of the unnamed inmates the Daily Mail named come forward themselves. And whether new discipline follows, the way it did with Tallman back in 2020.

Family Killer Chris Watts Reportedly Has Relationships With Men In Prison

The source nobody will name

The Daily Mail broke the story on November 11, 2026. Chris Watts, it reported, has had same-sex relationships with other prisoners at Dodge Correctional Institution in Wisconsin. He's serving five consecutive life sentences there, with no chance of parole, ever.

The source is a prison employee the Daily Mail didn't name. "Younger guys flock to Chris," the employee told the paper. "He's really got a hold over them and they'll usually do whatever he wants."

Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
Vinnie Uncensored: one free email every Sunday.

That same employee said Watts was recently pulled away from another male inmate after guards grew suspicious the two had an "inappropriate" relationship. "There have been times where it's pretty obvious something happened. When I say these guys will do anything for him, I mean anything," the employee said. "There is some thinking among guards that these relationships are too intimate."

Wonderwall, RadarOnline, The Tab and Newsner have all repeated the Daily Mail's reporting since, citing the same employee and the same former inmates. Newsner says plainly the claims "have not been independently verified," and no outlet in this reporting got the Wisconsin Department of Corrections to confirm anything on the record.

The murders that ended three lives

Watts is 41 now. Back in November 2018, he pleaded guilty to murdering his pregnant wife, Shanann Watts, and their two daughters, Bella, 4, and Celeste, 3, in Colorado that August.

He strangled Shanann. He smothered Bella and Celeste. Then he buried Shanann's body in a shallow grave at an oil site and put his daughters' bodies in separate crude oil tanks.

Watts has said he did it to clear the way for a relationship with Nichol Kessinger, a coworker he was having an affair with when the murders happened. The case became the 2020 Netflix documentary "American Murder: The Family Next Door."

"Younger guys flock to Chris. He's really got a hold over them and they'll usually do whatever he wants," — prison employee, told the Daily Mail

A relationship guards already caught once

This isn't the first time Watts' relationships with male inmates have raised eyebrows. Guards found his underwear, petroleum jelly and baby oil inside the cell of fellow inmate Dylan Tallman back in 2020. Tallman was 38 at the time.

The two men grew close while housed in neighboring cells, according to prison records. They'd talk for hours through an electrical outlet connecting the cells, one they nicknamed the "holy outlet." They also wrote Christian devotionals together and called themselves "brothers in spirit." Guards disciplined both men and split them up.

Tallman got out in 2021, after serving time on drug charges. He's always denied the relationship turned sexual. Asked about these newest allegations, he told the Daily Mail, "Nothing surprises me anymore. A lot happens in prison."

The Daily Mail says it was given the names of three other men suspected of sexual relationships with Watts. None of them agreed to talk on the record. One anonymous former inmate called his connection to Watts "intimate." "We were as close as two men can be," he said. "I'm not saying that nothing happened, but not everything that you probably think. It's not sex, it's something more."

The fiancée who called herself Lizzie Watts

Separate from the same-sex relationship claims, Watts was engaged until recently to a woman named Lizzie Henderson. The Tab reports she's a real estate agent who moved to Wisconsin to be near him. She started calling herself "Lizzie Watts," and applied to marry him inside the prison system. Visitor records cited by the outlet show she visited him 20 times in 2025 and spent Christmas Day with him in 2024.

Watts recently called off that engagement, the Daily Mail reports, allegedly after his mother, Cindy, pushed him to reconsider it. "Chris can't be alone. He needs constant affection and attention, and he'll get it from whoever is available," Cheryln Cadle, a true-crime author and regular pen pal of Watts, told the Daily Mail.

The claims that predate the prison cell

Questions about Watts and men go back further than prison. In late 2018, a man named Trent Bolte claimed he'd had a secret, 10-month relationship with Watts before the murders. The two allegedly met in hotel rooms and at a cabin in Wyoming. The FBI looked into it and couldn't back up his account. Watts has denied knowing him.

Separately, a hairdresser named Amanda McMahon told the Daily Mail this past summer that she had an affair with Watts the year before the murders. They met on Tinder. She described their sex as "animalistic" and "aggressive."

Across all five outlets that picked up this story, the claims trace back to the same source. One unnamed prison employee, plus a handful of anonymous former inmates, is the entire foundation for what's being said about current same-sex relationships inside Dodge Correctional. Tallman is the only person named in connection with the earlier incident that was actually documented and disciplined.

Vinnie on air

What Vinnie has said about this case

“I do believe he was cheating and that this would be a brilliant way to pull a Chris Watts, but that's too much.”

Vinnie Politan on his show, “Did Patrick Clancy Do It?” (August 10, 2026)

What happens next

There's no court date coming out of any of this. Watts is already serving five consecutive life sentences with no parole, full stop. What's still open: whether the Wisconsin Department of Corrections ever puts anything on the record. Whether any of the unnamed inmates the Daily Mail named come forward themselves. And whether new discipline follows, the way it did with Tallman back in 2020.

The legal read

How this plays in court

A prosecutor weighing this kind of reporting starts with sourcing. The central claims rest on one unnamed prison employee, quoted across five different outlets, plus a handful of anonymous former inmates. Nothing in the coverage reviewed includes an on-record statement from the Wisconsin Department of Corrections.

The 2020 Tallman incident is the one piece of documented, corroborated conduct in this story: physical items found in a cell, and an actual disciplinary record. That puts it on a different evidentiary tier than the current, undocumented claims.

Consensual relationships between adult inmates, even when they break prison rules, are a disciplinary matter for corrections officials, not a criminal one. Nothing in this reporting alleges coercion or a new charge.

Any defense against reputational claims like these leans on one thing: the anonymity of the sources, and the outlets' own admission that the allegations are unverified.

Sources. This report draws on the following coverage; quotes are reproduced as those outlets printed them.
  • Wonderwall: Killer Chris Watts has intimate relationships in prison: Report
  • Daily Mail: Chris Watts' gay prison sex revealed: Guards catch killer dad
  • RadarOnline: Chris Watts' Alleged Prison Intimacy Exposed: 'Younger Guys Flock to Him'
  • The Tab: ‘Young guys flock to him’: Chris Watts has had multiple relationships with men while in jail
  • Newsner: Chris Watts reportedly separated from male prisoner
Vinnie Politan is a former prosecutor and veteran trial anchor.
Vinnie Uncensored · every Sunday
Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
One email every Sunday: the week's biggest cases, the real charges, nothing softened. Free. Unsubscribe anytime.