Convicted YouTube Mom Ruby Franke Branded 'a Monster' By Her Own Eldest Daughter
Four years ago, police pulled Shari Franke's malnourished siblings out of a house in Utah. Now she's sent the parole board deciding her mother's fate a blunt warning, in writing: "She has been a monster her entire adult life." Ruby Franke's parole hearing is Dec. 7.
Case at a glance
- Ruby Franke — Former YouTube influencer, convicted
- Ruby Franke's eldest daughter — Author of letter to parole board, victim
Next: Ruby Franke and Jodi Hildebrandt go before the Utah Board of Pardons and Parole separately, but back-to-back, on Dec. 7. The board will weigh Shari Franke's written statement along with the rest of the record in deciding whether either woman is released or stays in prison within her four-to-30-year range. No outlet in this coverage has reported the hearing's outcome or a decision date.

A letter, not an appearance
Shari Franke skipped the hearing room. She sent an email instead.
Ruby Franke's daughter is 23. Ahead of her mother's Dec. 7 parole hearing, she wrote to the Utah Board of Pardons and Parole. She had one ask: keep Ruby locked up, and deny parole to Ruby's former business partner, Jodi Hildebrandt, too. The letter was obtained by Utah outlet KUTV and reported by People, Newsweek and E! News. It did not ask for leniency. It did not offer forgiveness.
"I will never accept Ruby's apology for what she has done," Shari wrote, according to KUTV's report of the letter. Then she went further: "She has been a monster her entire adult life, and there's no way that's changed in 3 years."
She won't be in the room Dec. 7. But she wanted the board to have her account in writing before anyone decides her mother's fate.
The mother behind 8 Passengers
Ruby Franke is 44. She built 8 Passengers, a YouTube channel with roughly two million subscribers, by filming daily life with her then-husband, Kevin Franke, and their six children.
Jodi Hildebrandt was a licensed counselor who ran a life-coaching program called ConneXions. Ruby grew close to her in the years before her arrest. Close enough to move into Hildebrandt's home in Ivins, Utah.
Shari was born in 2003, the oldest of Ruby and Kevin's six children. Since her mother's 2023 arrest, she has publicly broken with Ruby and written a memoir, The House of My Mother, according to E! News.
"She has been a monster her entire adult life, and there's no way that's changed in 3 years." — Shari Franke, in a statement to the Utah Board of Pardons and Parole, as reported by KUTV
The sentence, and who controls it
In December 2023, Ruby Franke and Jodi Hildebrandt each pleaded guilty to four counts of aggravated child abuse. Two months later, in February 2024, a judge handed each woman four consecutive terms of one to 15 years. Stacked together, that's a range of four to 30 years in prison.
Utah runs on indeterminate sentencing. The judge set the outer boundaries; the Board of Pardons and Parole, not the court, decides how much of that range each woman actually serves. Neither could walk free before hitting a mandatory minimum of 48 months. Both have now passed that mark.
Both women go before the board back-to-back on Dec. 7. Hildebrandt faces no additional charges beyond the four counts tied to Ruby's children. Shari's letter calls her "not sorry" and "one of the most dangerous people I know," but those are her characterizations, not findings by a court.
A boy climbs out a window
It became public in August 2023. Ruby's then-12-year-old son climbed out a window at Hildebrandt's Ivins home and ran to a neighbor for help. Police who found him described a boy who was emaciated, with open wounds and duct tape still on his extremities, according to a probable cause affidavit reported by NBC News and cited by E! News.
Officers searching the home found his 9-year-old sister in the same condition, malnourished, sitting alone in an empty closet. The Washington County Attorney's Office described her as "petrified," per evidence E! News reviewed.
Both kids ended up in the hospital. Ruby and Hildebrandt were arrested on aggravated child abuse charges not long after.
Shari's letter goes further than the charges filed. She alleges her mother also abused an older brother, Chad, growing up, allegations for which Ruby has never been charged or convicted. "She has never taken accountability" for that, Shari wrote, per Newsweek's report of the letter.
Nightmares, silence, and one apology
The last time Shari saw her mother face to face was around four years ago. She called it "the most stressful experience of my life." Ruby told her then that speaking out publicly meant she no longer wanted to be part of the family, per People's reporting on the letter.
She told the board she still has nightmares "at least weekly," dreams about being trapped in her mother's home trying to protect her younger siblings. She believes the abuse never would have stopped on its own: "Ruby would not have stopped what she was doing unless my brother had miraculously saved himself and my sister. Ruby would have killed them," she wrote, according to Newsweek. That's her belief, not a finding by prosecutors or the court.
On remorse, Shari wrote that Ruby stayed "stoic and silent" through her interrogations. The apologies only started once Ruby learned Hildebrandt had turned on her. Her family is better off now, Shari said: "For the first time in our lives, my family is happy. We are happy without Ruby," per E! News.
Neither Ruby Franke nor Jodi Hildebrandt has said a word publicly about Shari's letter. The coverage reviewed for this story has no statement from either woman, or their attorneys, addressing it.
What Vinnie has said about this case
“Ruby Franke and Jodi Hildebrandt were sentenced to four to 30 years in prison for aggravated child abuse.”
Vinnie Politan on his show, “It's Too Quiet in the Guthrie Case! Tangent Podcast 📱” (February 21, 2026)
“Ruby Franke and Jodi Hildebrandt were sentenced to four to 30 years in prison for aggravated child abuse.”
Vinnie Politan on his show, “It's Too Quiet in the Guthrie Case! Tangent Podcast” (February 20, 2026)
What happens next
Ruby Franke and Jodi Hildebrandt go before the Utah Board of Pardons and Parole separately, but back-to-back, on Dec. 7. The board will weigh Shari Franke's written statement along with the rest of the record in deciding whether either woman is released or stays in prison within her four-to-30-year range. No outlet in this coverage has reported the hearing's outcome or a decision date.
How this plays in court
A parole board isn't retrying the case. It's deciding how much of an already-imposed four-to-30-year range Ruby Franke and Jodi Hildebrandt actually serve. That's why victim-impact statements like Shari Franke's carry real weight, even though they aren't evidence of new crimes.
The board will likely focus on what each woman has done since sentencing: program participation, institutional conduct, and whether either has taken responsibility beyond blaming the other in the board's own interviews. Shari's letter directly argues Ruby has not.
Any defense response would likely stress that both women already pleaded guilty and are serving the sentence a judge imposed. It would also push back on allegations outside the charged conduct, like the claims involving Chad, since those were never charged or proven in court.
The board will also have to separate Shari's firsthand account of the charged conduct from her speculation about what might have happened without her brother's escape. Parole boards typically weigh the former far more heavily than the latter.
- People.com: Ruby Franke’s Daughter Shari Says Mom ‘Has Been a Monster Her Entire Adult Life’ in Statement to Parole Board
- Newsweek: Shari Franke Gives Mom Ruby Franke Advice Ahead of Parole Hearing
- E! News: Ruby Franke's Daughter Shari Franke Calls Her a "Monster" in Plea to Utah Parole Board