Southwark Crown Court

Russell Brand's Old Defenders Go Silent As New Accusers Come Forward

· How we report

A jury found Russell Brand guilty of rape and three counts of sexual assault. A judge gave him 10 years and six months. Since then, six more women have come forward with accusations against him. And the commentators who once rushed to his defense, Katie Hopkins among them, have mostly gone quiet instead of walking away.

Case at a glance

  • Russell Brand — subject

Next: The Metropolitan Police have confirmed Brand remains under investigation over two more rape allegations, separate from the four counts he's already been sentenced for. British police also told The Times they're pursuing additional criminal allegations, following the newspaper's latest investigation into the six women who came forward after sentencing. No date for any new charging decision or hearing shows up in the coverage reviewed.

Every report on the Russell Brand case →

Russell Brand's Old Defenders Go Silent As New Accusers Come Forward

A split verdict after four weeks

Russell Brand stood in the dock at Southwark Crown Court on Thursday, Nov. 5. A jury found him guilty of rape and three counts of sexual assault. He is 51. The verdict came after four weeks of testimony. The same jury acquitted him on two further rape counts and one count of attempted indecent assault. Prosecutors had brought seven charges in total, built on accounts from six women describing incidents stretching from 1999 to 2009, according to The Hollywood Reporter.

The rape conviction traces back to one night in early 2009. Brand had just finished a stand-up show at the Hammersmith Apollo. He picked a 21-year-old woman out of the crowd and brought her home to Hampstead. Consensual sex began. Then, according to the judge's sentencing remarks as reported by The Guardian and The Hollywood Reporter, he anally raped her without a condom. He kept going after she asked him twice to stop.

Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
Vinnie Uncensored: one free email every Sunday.

The three sexual assault convictions came from three separate women. In 2004, he groped an MTV employee at a birthday party in Soho. In 2005, he grabbed and kissed a woman who worked at the radio station Choice FM, in front of his entourage. In 2009, during a Channel 4 recording project, he forced a woman to give him a massage and pressed his head into her lap.

Brand's lawyers asked the judge to let him go home for the weekend, to see his three children. Mr. Justice Joel Bennathan said no. Brand spent the weekend in a London prison cell. On Monday, Nov. 9, he was back at Southwark Crown Court, where Bennathan sentenced him to 10 years and six months.

A comedian, a wife, a whistleblower

Brand built three different public lives before this one. He started as an MTV host and a comedian. He became a Hollywood actor, known for Get Him to the Greek and Forgetting Sarah Marshall. More recently, he reinvented himself as a Christian spiritual influencer. He is married to author Laura Brand; they have three children together. His first wife was pop singer Katy Perry. They married in 2010 and divorced a little over a year later.

Mr. Justice Joel Bennathan presided over the trial and handed down the sentence. Barrister Ian Winter KC led Brand's defense. The four convicted counts came from four separate women. None of them is named in the coverage reviewed for this story.

Jemima Goldsmith dated Brand for about a year, back in 2014. The Hollywood Reporter identifies her as the whistleblower who approached Channel 4's then-head of news, Dorothy Byrne, in 2019. That conversation led to a joint investigation by Channel 4's Dispatches and The Times and Sunday Times. This week, Goldsmith publicly accused Brand of "violence, coercive control and abuse" during their relationship. She said she had police remove him from her home in 2014 "during a violent incident," according to the Los Angeles Times.

Two of the six additional women who came forward after sentencing go by first names only, Alex and Vicky, in the new Times of London and Sunday Times investigation. The rest are described but not named.

"Whatever women wear, wherever they go, whatever they drink, they retain the right to say no and demand justice in the criminal courts when sexual predators like you, Mr. Brand, act without their consent," — Mr. Justice Joel Bennathan, via The Guardian

Reading the sentence between the lines

Under the law applied in Brand's trial, rape means sexual intercourse without consent. Sexual assault covers unwanted sexual touching, including groping, that falls short of rape. The jury convicted Brand of one rape and three sexual assaults. But it acquitted him on two rape counts and one count of attempted indecent assault. That split means jurors weren't convinced beyond reasonable doubt on those specific allegations, even as they convicted him on others. It's a sign they weighed each woman's account on its own evidence, rather than handing down one blanket judgment on Brand's character.

English judges can push a sentence toward the top of the range by weighing aggravating factors, like abuse of power or a betrayed position of trust. Bennathan told Brand his conduct reflected a "casual, arrogant disregard of any woman's right to say no." He cited "staggering arrogance" in the assault committed in front of Brand's entourage. That's the kind of language a judge uses to justify a sentence above the ordinary midpoint.

Before sentencing, crime commentator Danny Shaw had put the likely range at four to 13 years, in a post cited by NPR. He noted the average UK rape sentence runs close to 10 years, with a legal maximum of life imprisonment. Bennathan's term of 10 years and six months lands above that average.

There's more to come, potentially. The Guardian reports that the Metropolitan Police have confirmed Brand remains under investigation over two further rape allegations. Those are separate from the four counts he's already been sentenced for. More charges remain possible.

Inside the courtroom, in their own words

Bennathan looked at Brand and told him plainly: "Whatever women wear, wherever they go, whatever they drink, they retain the right to say no and demand justice in the criminal courts when sexual predators like you, Mr. Brand, act without their consent," according to The Guardian.

On the assault committed in front of Brand's entourage, the judge didn't mince words: "No doubt your companions thought it was outrageous laddish behaviour that only you could get away with. It was outrageous and possibly laddish, but also a criminal sexual offence, and as it turns out you haven't got away with it," The Guardian reported.

Ian Winter KC, Brand's barrister, made his case for leniency: "This should be regarded as a man who went too far and overrode consent that had been given," per The Guardian. Brand barely reacted as the sentence came down. As he was led from the dock, he told his wife, Laura, "We'll be OK." She answered, "I love you," then left the courtroom in tears, The Guardian reported.

One of the women Brand raped read her victim impact statement to the court: "Even now, I feel that I am living with the trauma of what happened. It is something I carry with me every day and it often feels never-ending," according to The Guardian.

The defenders who went quiet

The headline on this story quotes commentator Katie Hopkins calling Brand's old defenders "running for cover." That exact quote doesn't turn up anywhere in the coverage reviewed for this story. What the record actually shows is close to the opposite. A Searchlight Magazine analysis of the public reaction found Hopkins herself among several prominent voices who defended Brand loudly when he was first accused in 2023. In the days after his conviction, she said nothing publicly.

Searchlight lists who said what. Elon Musk wrote in 2023, "I support Russell Brand. That man is not evil." Tucker Carlson suggested the allegations were retaliation for Brand "question[ing] the war in Ukraine." Tommy Robinson told his followers, "Welcome to the club," and later claimed Brand "faced no allegations until... he spoke against big pharma." Tristan Tate, brother of Andrew Tate, predicted the accusers would demand money: "I'd bet my life on it." And Hopkins herself had warned in 2023 that the allegations risked driving Brand to suicide: "They want to eviscerate him from the planet."

None of them, Hopkins included, had commented publicly as of Searchlight's report this week. There's one exception. GB News presenter Beverley Turner called Brand "a hero" on air back in 2023. This week, instead of addressing the verdict, she pointed her followers back to that same column. In it, she had written: "Maybe someone will emerge with forensic and visual evidence proving that he was indeed a rapist. At that point, I will hold up my hands and say that I was wrong about the unlikeliness of a conviction." She still hasn't said whether the convictions changed her mind.

Not everyone in Brand's old orbit went quiet. Broadcaster Jonathan Ross co-hosted a 2008 radio segment with Brand that became its own scandal. This week, Ross said he is "horrified" by Brand's crimes and was "genuinely unaware" of his conduct, according to The Hollywood Reporter.

What happens next

The Metropolitan Police have confirmed Brand remains under investigation over two more rape allegations, separate from the four counts he's already been sentenced for. British police also told The Times they're pursuing additional criminal allegations, following the newspaper's latest investigation into the six women who came forward after sentencing. No date for any new charging decision or hearing shows up in the coverage reviewed.

The legal read

How this plays in court

A prosecutor building a multi-complainant sexual offense case expects juries to weigh each count on its own evidence, not render one verdict on a defendant's character. The split result here, four convictions and three acquittals, reflects exactly that count-by-count scrutiny.

Defense counsel's argument that media coverage "poisoned the well of justice" is the kind of pretrial-publicity claim that typically resurfaces on appeal. Whether it gains traction depends on what the trial record shows about jury vetting and instructions, not on the volume of prior press coverage.

Sentencing judges lean on aggravating factors to justify a term above the guideline average. Think abuse of power, breach of trust, conduct carried out in front of witnesses who did nothing. Bennathan's remarks about "staggering arrogance" and conduct before an enabling entourage read as exactly that kind of enhancement.

New allegations surfacing after a conviction, like the six women in the Times investigation, don't affect a sentence already imposed. But prosecutors deciding whether to pursue any of them as new charges would look for corroboration beyond testimony. That means texts, messages or photographs, the kind the newspaper investigation says it reviewed.

Sources. This report draws on the following coverage; quotes are reproduced as those outlets printed them.
  • Searchlight Magazine: The sound of silence: Russell Brand’s far-right cheerleaders fall strangely quiet
  • NPR: Russell Brand to learn sentence after being found guilty of rape and sexual assault
  • Los Angeles Times: Russell Brand accused of sexual misconduct by six more women following conviction: report
  • The Hollywood Reporter: “Evil All Along”: How Russell Brand Got Caught
  • The Guardian: Russell Brand sentenced to more than 10 years in prison for rape and sexual assault
Vinnie Politan is a former prosecutor and veteran trial anchor.
Vinnie Uncensored · every Sunday
Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
One email every Sunday: the week's biggest cases, the real charges, nothing softened. Free. Unsubscribe anytime.