Judge Denies Kimberlee Singler More Time, Forces Not Guilty Plea In Her Kids' Deaths
Investigators didn't know Kimberlee Singler's two children had been shot until the autopsy came back. Singler told detectives she already knew. She pleaded not guilty Wednesday in El Paso County to murder charges in their 2023 deaths, after a judge denied her lawyers' request for more time.
Case at a glance
- Kimberlee Singler — Colorado Springs mother charged with killing two of her children, accused
- Aden Wentz — 7-year-old son, victim
- Ellie Wentz — 9-year-old daughter, victim
- Eric Faddis — Legal analyst not connected to the case
Next: Singler is due back in court in February, with her trial currently set for April, according to KKTV and KOAA News 5. Neither outlet has released exact dates for either proceeding. Whether the defense's push for those ex-husband case records resurfaces before trial remains to be seen.

The 911 call that became a false story
It was the early hours of Dec. 19, 2023, when Kimberlee Singler called 911 from her apartment in northeast Colorado Springs. An intruder had broken in, she told dispatchers. He'd attacked her and her three children, she said — and officers who responded heard the same story.
Inside the home, they found two of her children already dead: her 7-year-old son, Aden, and her 9-year-old daughter, Ellie Wentz. Her third child, 11 at the time, survived. Singler and her surviving daughter both ended up in the hospital with injuries, according to KKTV.
Nobody knew yet how the children had died. KKTV and KOAA News 5 both report medical examiners hadn't determined the children were shot. But in interviews with detectives, Singler said she already knew — she knew before the autopsy ever confirmed it.
Citing autopsy records, the Colorado Springs Gazette reported that both children had been shot in the head, and that each had cuts to the neck. They'd also been drugged with a sleeping medication — one prescribed to Singler. The other outlets reviewed for this story don't include that detail.
At first, police treated Singler the way her story told them to: as a victim of the attack she described, not a suspect.
The gun, the DNA and the staged break-in
Investigators found a gun inside the apartment, covered in blood. Blood and DNA testing matched it to Singler herself, according to arrest papers — her own blood, her own DNA, on the weapon used in her children's deaths. The apartment sat in the 5300 block of Palomino Ranch Point.
That evidence pointed investigators toward one conclusion: Singler had handled the gun that killed the two children, according to arrest papers cited by KOAA. The break-in she'd described on the 911 call? Investigators later determined it never happened, according to the Gazette.
Soon after her children died, Singler left the country for the United Kingdom. She spent roughly two years there before authorities arrested her and brought her back to Colorado in December 2025 — extradition, the formal legal process for returning someone from another country to face charges, and the reason the case took as long as it did.
"The delays in this case that has spanned years now are attributable to Ms. Singler," — Eric Faddis, legal analyst, to KKTV
The people this case revolves around
Kimberlee Singler is 38, according to the Gazette, the mother of all three children involved. Aden, 7, and Ellie Wentz, 9, are the two who died. Their sibling, 11 at the time, survived and hasn't been named in the coverage reviewed for this story.
Singler's defense team is pushing to get records from a separate, unrelated case involving her ex-husband — a case in which, the defense says, Singler was the victim. None of the outlets reviewed name the ex-husband or say what that case involved.
Eric Faddis, a Colorado defense attorney with no connection to this case, gave KKTV outside legal analysis.
The charges and Wednesday's plea
First-degree murder. That's what Singler faces for the deaths of Aden and Ellie, along with additional charges tied to her surviving child's injuries, according to KOAA. Under Colorado law, a first-degree murder charge means prosecutors have to prove the killing was deliberate — a higher bar than lesser homicide charges, and the one that carries the harshest sentence if they clear it.
Wednesday, just before noon at the El Paso County Courthouse, Singler pleaded not guilty to all of it. A not guilty plea at this stage doesn't say anything about the evidence. It's procedural — it moves the case toward trial and preserves a defendant's right to fight every charge in front of a jury.
Before the judge entered that plea, her attorneys spoke up. They weren't ready, they said. They were still trying to get the ex-husband case records they believe back up their client's account.
Judge denies the defense's request for more time
The judge said no. The case needed to move forward, the judge ruled, and the not guilty plea went in Wednesday over the defense's objection — they'd argued for more time to gather records.
That ruling capped off a case that's already stretched nearly three years, most of it eaten up by the roughly two years Singler spent in the United Kingdom before her extradition last December.
What the legal analysis says about the delay
Why'd the judge rule this way? Eric Faddis, speaking to KKTV as an outside legal expert, said it likely comes down to how long this case has already dragged on. "The delays in this case that has spanned years now are attributable to Ms. Singler," Faddis told KKTV. "And so she can't just sort of delay this forever and keep requesting to postpone this."
There's a silver lining for the defense buried in how this case started, Faddis said. Police treating Singler as a victim at first could actually help her at trial. "The fact that police initially treated her as a victim may actually lend credence to the defense's version," he told KKTV. "If they come at trial and say this was an alternative suspect, and in fact the police initially agreed with us, well, that carries some weight."
What happens next
Singler is due back in court in February, with her trial currently set for April, according to KKTV and KOAA News 5. Neither outlet has released exact dates for either proceeding. Whether the defense's push for those ex-husband case records resurfaces before trial remains to be seen.
How this plays in court
Expect prosecutors to point straight at the gun. It was covered in blood, and that blood — along with Singler's DNA — was hers. She'd told police an intruder did this. The evidence inside her own apartment says otherwise.
The timeline is the other exhibit prosecutors will lean on hard. Investigators didn't confirm the children had been shot until the autopsy came back. Singler told detectives she already knew — before that confirmation ever happened. Prosecutors will argue that timeline only makes sense if she had firsthand knowledge of how the shooting went down.
The defense has its own angle, and it starts with how this case began. Officers treated Singler as a victim, not a suspect, in the hours right after the shooting. Expect the defense to lean on that early read to argue for an alternative suspect, and to keep pushing for those ex-husband case records to back up a broader victim narrative.
A jury will have to weigh the forensic evidence and the holes in Singler's own statements against whatever alternative the defense offers. Jurors will also likely hear argument about the nearly two years Singler spent out of the country before extradition. Prosecutors will frame that as flight. The defense will need another explanation.
- KKTV: Judge Denies Kimberlee Singler More Time, Forces Not Guilty Plea In Her Kids' Deaths
- Colorado Springs Gazette: Kimberlee Singler pleads not guilty to killing her kids
- KOAA News 5: Colorado Springs mother accused of killing two of her children pleads not guilty