Fort Bragg

The Word Written In Blood That Helped Convict Him

· How we report

Colette MacDonald was three months pregnant when she and her two little girls were stabbed and beaten to death at their home at Fort Bragg. Her husband, Army doctor Jeffrey MacDonald, said four strangers did it. A single word scrawled in her blood helped put him in prison for life.

Case at a glance

  • Jeffrey MacDonald — subject

Next: Few American murder cases have produced more appeals, more retried legal theories, or more books than this one. Nothing in the record reviewed here points to a hearing on the horizon. Jeffrey MacDonald is still locked up at the Butner Medium II Federal Correctional Institution in Butner, North Carolina, still saying four intruders did it. Any future filings or parole proceedings aren't detailed in the sources for this article.

The Word Written In Blood That Helped Convict Him

The Green Beret doctor's house on Castle Drive

That December, Colette MacDonald wrote to college friends that her life had "never [been] so normal or happy," and that the baby due in July would complete the family. Two months later, she and both daughters were dead.

Just before Christmas 1969, MacDonald secretly bought his daughters a Shetland pony. Kimberley, 5, and Kristen, 2, named him Trooper. The pony was a preview of the family's planned move to a farm in Connecticut. By February 1970, the four of them — soon to be five — were living at 544 Castle Drive, in the part of Fort Bragg reserved for married officers. Colette was about three months pregnant with their first son.

Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
Vinnie Uncensored: one free email every Sunday.

MacDonald was born October 12, 1943, in Jamaica, Queens, and grew up on Long Island. He met Colette Stevenson in eighth grade at Patchogue-Medford High School. The two married on September 14, 1963, in New York City, after she got pregnant during his sophomore year at Princeton.

He finished medical school at Northwestern in 1968, trained in thoracic surgery through a brutal internship in New York, and joined the Army in June 1969. He volunteered for Special Forces training and was assigned that August as group surgeon to the 3rd Special Forces Group at Fort Bragg. By 1970, he was a captain.

Four intruders, one survivor, three bodies

On the afternoon of February 16, 1970, MacDonald took his daughters to see the pony. They were home by 5:45 p.m. Colette made supper, then left for an evening class at Fort Bragg's North Carolina University extension.

MacDonald's account picks up from there: he played with his daughters, put Kristen down around 7 p.m., and let Kimberley stay up a little longer. The two of them watched part of Laugh-In together before he fell asleep himself.

Then, MacDonald told investigators, his wife and daughter started screaming. He said four intruders — three men and a woman — had come in through the unlocked rear door. They went after him, his wife, and his children with knives, clubs, and an ice pick. According to the Wikipedia account of the case, MacDonald said the intruders chanted phrases including "Acid is groovy, kill the pigs," as they attacked.

Colette and both daughters were killed. MacDonald survived. Investigators and prosecutors later said his injuries were far less severe than the wounds on his wife and children — a disparity that became central to the case against him. The word "PIG" was found written on the headboard in the bedroom in Colette's blood.

"never [been] so normal or happy" — Colette MacDonald, in a letter to college friends weeks before the murders, as recounted in the Wikipedia account of the case

A conviction that decades of appeals couldn't undo

Prosecutors argued the crime scene had been staged by MacDonald himself to resemble a cult-style home invasion, pointing to the mismatch between his injuries and the fatal wounds suffered by Colette, Kimberley, and Kristen as core physical evidence of his guilt.

Jeffrey MacDonald was convicted in August 1979 of murdering his pregnant wife and two daughters. He has always proclaimed his innocence and has continued to maintain, through decades of incarceration, that four intruders were responsible. According to the sourced record, appellate courts reviewing the case have pointed to strong physical evidence supporting his guilt.

The case has generated what the sourced material describes as one of the most litigated murder cases in American criminal history, producing extensive appellate and legal proceedings over the decades since the original trial. MacDonald is currently incarcerated at the Butner Medium II Federal Correctional Institution in Butner, North Carolina.

One word in blood, two interpretations

The word written in Colette's blood on the headboard — "PIG" — echoed language associated with the Manson Family murders roughly six months earlier, in which the word "PIG" was famously written in blood at the Tate residence. Prosecutors treated the similarity as evidence that the Fort Bragg crime scene had been deliberately arranged to mimic a notorious, well-publicized cult killing rather than reflect an actual intruder attack. MacDonald's own account placed the phrase "kill the pigs" in the mouths of the intruders he described, tying his narrative directly to the writing found at the scene.

Was it outside attackers invoking the era's most infamous murders? Or MacDonald staging the scene himself to match them? Few physical details in this case have been argued harder than that single word, built as the case is on competing readings of the same evidence.

What happens next

Few American murder cases have produced more appeals, more retried legal theories, or more books than this one. Nothing in the record reviewed here points to a hearing on the horizon. Jeffrey MacDonald is still locked up at the Butner Medium II Federal Correctional Institution in Butner, North Carolina, still saying four intruders did it. Any future filings or parole proceedings aren't detailed in the sources for this article.

The legal read

How this plays in court

A prosecutor looks hardest at the evidence that doesn't fit the suspect's story. Here, that's the gap between Jeffrey MacDonald's injuries and the fatal wounds on his wife and daughters. A staged-scene theory lives or dies on that gap. If four people were really overpowered by intruders, the one who survived should look like he fought for his life — not like he walked away largely unhurt.

The defense's strongest card is the one MacDonald played from day one: outside intruders did it. He has never dropped that story, not even decades into incarceration. A defense team builds reasonable doubt by going after the chain of custody and the thoroughness of the original 1970 crime scene work. It also goes after anything that supports a version of events besides the prosecution's.

A jury weighing a message written at a crime scene has to ask two questions: who could have written it, and what was it meant to convey? Prosecutors read it as an attempt to mimic the Manson-family murders and distract from a domestic crime. That reading only holds up if everything else in the room matches a staged scene, not a home invasion.

Appellate courts that have reviewed this case point to the overall weight of the physical evidence, not any one clue, as the basis for upholding the conviction. In a case litigated this long, no single piece of evidence carries a jury or a judge alone.

Sources. This report draws on the following coverage; quotes are reproduced as those outlets printed them.
  • Wikipedia: The Word Written In Blood That Helped Convict Him
Vinnie Politan is a former prosecutor and veteran trial anchor.
Vinnie Uncensored · every Sunday
Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
One email every Sunday: the week's biggest cases, the real charges, nothing softened. Free. Unsubscribe anytime.