THE PLEA DEAL

He Confessed To 13 Kills And Never Faced A Jury

· How we report

Joseph James DeAngelo stood in a California courtroom and admitted to thirteen murders and decades of rape — then walked away from a trial no juror would ever sit for. His guilty plea bought him life, not death, and bought silence where testimony should have been.

Case at a glance

  • Joseph James DeAngelo — subject

Next: DeAngelo's own case closed on August 21, 2020, with his sentencing. He is not appealing a plea he entered voluntarily. But the technique that caught him keeps reopening other files. Boulder police and the Boulder County district attorney said this week they still aren't ready to test the aging, mixed DNA sample from the JonBenét Ramsey case. They haven't signed off on using the same forensic genetic genealogy approach that identified DeAngelo. Genealogist Barbara Rae-Venter — who identified DeAngelo in 63 days in 2018 — has gone on to help close more than a dozen other cold cases with the method.

He Confessed To 13 Kills And Never Faced A Jury

Break-ins across California, then silence

He broke into homes across California at night, again and again, between 1974 and 1986. County after county chased him for years without ever knowing they were chasing the same man.

It started in the San Joaquin Valley: at least 120 burglaries, one murder. Then Sacramento County, where he raped at least 51 women and killed two more people between 1976 and 1979. Then he moved south, into Santa Barbara, Ventura and Orange counties, where he killed at least ten more people between 1979 and 1986.

Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
Vinnie Uncensored: one free email every Sunday.

Different counties gave him different names: the East Area Rapist, the Original Night Stalker, the Visalia Ransacker. Nobody connected them until 2001, when DNA testing proved the East Area Rapist and the Original Night Stalker were the same man. Then, after 1986, he just stopped. He went dark for more than three decades.

The man nobody suspected

Joseph DeAngelo was born November 8, 1945, in Bath, New York. He served in the Navy during Vietnam. Then he built a law-enforcement résumé: a degree in police science, a bachelor's in criminal justice. He wore a badge in Exeter from 1973 to 1976, then in Auburn from 1976 to 1979. Auburn fired him in 1979, after police arrested him for shoplifting a hammer and a can of dog repellent.

He married Sharon Marie Huddle in 1973, and they had three daughters. His eldest daughter called him a "perfect father," according to Wikipedia's account of the case. Neither she nor his wife ever suspected him of anything. Huddle filed for divorce in July 2018, months after his arrest.

Before Huddle, DeAngelo had been engaged to Bonnie Jean Colwell, a nursing student he met at Sierra College. She broke off the engagement in 1971. Victims later told investigators they heard him yell out the name "Bonnie" during some of the attacks. She attended his 2020 sentencing, standing with his survivors.

Michelle McNamara was a true-crime writer who got obsessed with the unsolved case in the mid-2000s. She's the one who coined the name "Golden State Killer," and it stuck. She died in her sleep on April 21, 2016, at age 46, from an undiagnosed heart condition combined with prescription medication. Her husband, researcher and editor finished her book, "I'll Be Gone in the Dark," which came out in February 2018 — two months before DeAngelo's arrest. She never got to see him identified.

"You'll be silent forever, and I'll be gone in the dark." — Joseph James DeAngelo, to a victim, as reported by AOL.com (Parade)

The confession that never went to trial

On April 24, 2018, California authorities charged 72-year-old DeAngelo with eight counts of first-degree murder, built on DNA evidence. Four months later, in August 2018, prosecutors added thirteen counts of kidnapping and related abduction attempts. That was the charging vehicle they had: California's statute of limitations on pre-2017 rape cases barred them from charging the 1970s-era rapes directly.

On June 29, 2020, DeAngelo pleaded guilty to multiple counts of murder and kidnapping. The plea bargain spared him the death penalty. In exchange, he admitted to numerous crimes he had never been formally charged with, including rapes the clock had already run out on.

DNA evidence tied him directly to eight of the murders, committed in Goleta, Ventura, Dana Point and Irvine. Two more killings in Goleta had no DNA, but investigators linked them by modus operandi. He pleaded guilty to three more: two in Rancho Cordova, one in Visalia. That's thirteen killings total. On August 21, 2020, a judge sentenced him to life in prison without the possibility of parole.

Because he pleaded guilty, no jury ever heard the DNA evidence. No jury heard survivor testimony, or any defense case at all. The investigation that took more than four decades to build never once reached a courtroom trial.

The DNA he threw away

The break came from GEDmatch, a free public genealogy database. Investigators uploaded a genetic profile built from decades-old crime scene DNA. They got matches to distant relatives, narrowed the family tree down, and then collected a DNA sample DeAngelo had thrown away in public. It matched.

Barbara Rae-Venter, the genealogist who worked the case, identified DeAngelo just 63 days after she got his genetic profile in 2018. It was one of the earliest major uses of forensic investigative genetic genealogy to crack a cold case. The technique has since helped identify more than 80 suspects in Rae-Venter's casework alone.

His former boss told reporters, "If he's worn a mask, he's done it very well," according to AOL.com. Café staff where he was a regular called him "Mr. Happy," not because he was — the outlet reported he was demanding and moody instead.

The line he used on his victims

During several attacks, DeAngelo told a victim, "You'll be silent forever, and I'll be gone in the dark," according to AOL.com's account. McNamara later used that line as the title of her posthumous book.

Rae-Venter has kept working cold cases since the DeAngelo breakthrough, and she's thought a lot about what the method means for families. She told Forensic Magazine: "When someone is deceased, that's the end of the trail. But for survivors, naming him means he is no longer a boogeyman."

There was no verdict for the survivors of DeAngelo's assaults, or the families of his victims, to hear read aloud in open court. The case ended with his own words at a plea hearing — and, a year later, with a judge's sentence of life without parole.

What happens next

DeAngelo's own case closed on August 21, 2020, with his sentencing. He is not appealing a plea he entered voluntarily. But the technique that caught him keeps reopening other files. Boulder police and the Boulder County district attorney said this week they still aren't ready to test the aging, mixed DNA sample from the JonBenét Ramsey case. They haven't signed off on using the same forensic genetic genealogy approach that identified DeAngelo. Genealogist Barbara Rae-Venter — who identified DeAngelo in 63 days in 2018 — has gone on to help close more than a dozen other cold cases with the method.

The legal read

How this plays in court

Prosecutors built this case on two different kinds of proof. Direct DNA matches tied DeAngelo to eight of the murders. Modus-operandi links covered two more murders that had no DNA. His own guilty plea covered the final three. That split would have forced the defense to fight each count on different ground, had the case ever gone to trial.

The plea bargain was a trade, not a gift. Prosecutors gave up the death penalty. In exchange, DeAngelo admitted to rapes that the statute of limitations on pre-2017 cases had already placed beyond their reach to charge directly. That's accountability a jury verdict could never have reached for those specific attacks.

Because DeAngelo pleaded guilty, no jury ever tested the DNA evidence. No jury tested the genetic-genealogy methodology, either, or the decades of concealment from his own family. All of that, a defense would otherwise have had standing to contest.

The kidnapping charges filed in August 2018 were the only charging vehicle available for conduct from the 1970s that prosecutors could no longer charge as rape. Defense attorneys in similar cold-case prosecutions routinely raise that limitation. They argue a plea was the state's only real option, not the defendant's.

Sources. This report draws on the following coverage; quotes are reproduced as those outlets printed them.
  • Wikipedia: He Confessed To 13 Kills And Never Faced A Jury
  • Forensic Magazine: Professor's Math Model Cracks Cold Cases Faster
  • The Colorado Sun: A new DNA technology could help find JonBenét Ramsey's killer. Boulder investigators say it isn't ready.
  • AOL.com: For 40 Years, the Golden State Killer Lived as a Neighbor, a Father, and an Ex Cop; He Was Finally Caught — Because a Dead Woman Never Stopped Looking
Vinnie Politan is a former prosecutor and veteran trial anchor.
Vinnie Uncensored · every Sunday
Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
One email every Sunday: the week's biggest cases, the real charges, nothing softened. Free. Unsubscribe anytime.