CHARGED

Felon Freed From Federal Prison Allegedly Stabs Man To Death At His Own Welcome-home Party

· How we report

Andre Smith, 42, went to a party to celebrate a friend's homecoming from federal prison. Richland County deputies say he left in a body bag. Cedrick Cunningham, 50 — a convicted armed career criminal — now faces murder charges in Hopkins, South Carolina, over the stabbing deputies say ended that celebration.

Case at a glance

  • Cedrick Cunningham — Defendant, charged with murder and weapon possession during a violent crime, charged
  • Andre Smith — 42-year-old man found dead in a car in Hopkins, South Carolina, victim

Next: No bond hearing. No arraignment. No first-appearance date — none of it shows up in the available coverage yet. Cunningham remains held at the Alvin S. Glenn Detention Center as of the most recent reporting. And one question still hangs out there with the Bureau of Prisons: local reporters have asked the agency to clarify Cunningham's actual custody status at the time of the killing, since federal records had him tied to a residential reentry office in Raleigh, North Carolina.

Felon Freed From Federal Prison Allegedly Stabs Man To Death At His Own Welcome-home Party

A welcome-home party, then a body in a car

Saturday, Back Swamp Road, Hopkins, South Carolina — a small community southeast of Columbia. Deputies rolled up and found a man slumped inside a car. He was 42-year-old Andre Smith. A large laceration cut across his chest. He was already dead, pronounced so right there at the scene, according to WIS News 10.

From there, investigators worked the case backward. Smith, it turned out, had just come from a party. The celebration was for Cedrick Cunningham, fresh out of federal prison. Somewhere in that party, authorities say, Cunningham and Smith got into it. The fight turned deadly.

Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
Vinnie Uncensored: one free email every Sunday.

The Richland County Sheriff's Office says that altercation ended with Cunningham allegedly stabbing Smith. Somehow, Smith made it to his own car. He drove off. He didn't get far before he was found dead, WIS News 10 reported. Two days later, on Monday, deputies charged Cunningham with murder and possession of a weapon during a violent crime.

The two men who crossed paths

Cedrick Cunningham is 50. He'd just walked out of federal prison, where he'd been serving time on a weapons conviction. The party that night was thrown to mark that release — his release.

Andre Smith was 42. Nothing in the available coverage says how he knew Cunningham, or why he was there. What's clear is that both men were at the same party when the fatal fight broke out.

The Richland County Sheriff's Office is running the investigation. As of Tuesday evening, Cunningham sat in the Alvin S. Glenn Detention Center.

Two new charges, one long record

Richland County has charged Cunningham with two counts: murder, and possession of a weapon during the commission of a violent crime. In South Carolina, a murder charge means prosecutors believe the killing wasn't an accident and wasn't legally justified. The weapons count stacks on top of that — a separate charge for using a weapon while committing the violent crime.

This isn't Cunningham's first time in the system. Federal records show a 10-year sentence, handed down in 2019, after he pleaded guilty to a weapons charge. His prior drug convictions were enough, court documents show, to label him an "armed career criminal" under the federal Armed Career Criminal Act — a designation that comes with mandatory minimum sentences for felons caught holding firearms.

In 2023, Cunningham asked a federal judge for compassionate release. The judge said no. So how did he end up free enough to be at a party in Hopkins? The available reporting doesn't spell it out. WIS News 10 says those details "were not immediately clear."

There's more murk here. A search of the Federal Bureau of Prisons website turned up Cunningham listed at a Residential Reentry Management office in Raleigh, North Carolina. That's usually a halfway house step, or home confinement — not full freedom. WIS has asked the Bureau of Prisons to clarify Cunningham's actual status at the time of the killing. No answer yet, as of the most recent reporting.

The silence from everyone involved

Right now, the public record is basically the sheriff's office talking through local reporters. Smith was found with a large laceration on his chest. He was pronounced dead at the scene. The stabbing, they say, followed a fight at Cunningham's release party.

Nobody on the record has given a direct quote yet — not a sheriff's spokesperson, not a prosecutor, not Cunningham's attorney, not Smith's family. WIS News 10 and its Gray Media partner stations say they've reached out to the Bureau of Prisons for clarification on Cunningham's release status. No response had been published as of the latest reports.

Nobody involved has gone on record yet, so there's no attributed statement from either side to weigh here. For now, all we have is the sheriff's office's account of what the investigation found.

What happens next

No bond hearing. No arraignment. No first-appearance date — none of it shows up in the available coverage yet. Cunningham remains held at the Alvin S. Glenn Detention Center as of the most recent reporting. And one question still hangs out there with the Bureau of Prisons: local reporters have asked the agency to clarify Cunningham's actual custody status at the time of the killing, since federal records had him tied to a residential reentry office in Raleigh, North Carolina.

The legal read

How this plays in court

Prosecutors will lean on the physical evidence first. That means the location of Smith's body in his own vehicle, the large laceration to his chest, and the timeline tying him to the same celebration as Cunningham. The core of the case comes down to two things: proving an altercation happened, and proving it was Cunningham who caused the fatal wound.

The defense will likely probe the gap between the alleged stabbing and Smith driving himself away from the scene. What happened in that window matters. It could become the point of dispute over exactly how and when the fatal injury occurred, and over who else, if anyone, was present.

Cunningham's federal record is not evidence of what happened at this party. The weapons conviction, the armed career criminal designation, the denied compassionate release — a jury would not hear any of it as proof he committed this killing. But if the case reaches trial, both sides will fight over whether, and how much, of that history becomes relevant.

A jury weighing a murder charge in South Carolina has to decide whether the killing was intentional and unlawful, as opposed to self-defense or a lesser degree of homicide. That distinction usually comes down to one question: who the physical evidence and any witnesses say started the altercation.

Sources. This report draws on the following coverage; quotes are reproduced as those outlets printed them.
  • live5news.com: Felon Freed From Federal Prison Allegedly Stabs Man To Death At His Own Welcome-home Party
  • WIS News 10: Richland County murder suspect was recently released from federal prison, deputies say
Vinnie Politan is a former prosecutor and veteran trial anchor.
Vinnie Uncensored · every Sunday
Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
One email every Sunday: the week's biggest cases, the real charges, nothing softened. Free. Unsubscribe anytime.