Long Island Postal Worker Caught On Camera Shopping Spree With Your Stolen Gift Card
A Long Island postal clerk admitted she ripped open outgoing mail, grabbed gift cards and lottery tickets for herself, then turned around and spent one of the stolen cards at a TJ Maxx the very next day — caught on camera, while investigators were already running a decoy to catch her.
Case at a glance
- Jovanni Jamison-Lewis — former Oakdale Post Office clerk, convicted
- Ray Tierney — Suffolk County District Attorney, official
Next: Jamison-Lewis is due back in court on Jan. 11, 2027, for sentencing before Acting Supreme Court Justice Richard I. Horowitz. Prosecutors haven't said what sentence they'll seek. Her attorney, Matthew Hereth, hadn't commented on the plea as of the most recent reporting.

The bait envelope, and the receipt that nailed her
Nov. 19, 2025 started like any other shift at the Oakdale Post Office on Long Island. Jovanni Jamison-Lewis worked the counter, surrounded by outgoing mail that customers had already sealed and dropped off, trusting it to reach wherever it was headed. Prosecutors say that's when she started pulling envelopes out of the bin and opening them herself.
Inside one envelope: a greeting card and a $175 TJ Maxx gift card. Inside another: a greeting card and three New York State Lottery scratch-off tickets. Jamison-Lewis opened both, pocketed the gift card and the tickets, then slid the empty greeting cards back inside and dropped the envelopes right back into the outgoing bin, according to Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney's office.
That timing wasn't an accident. The envelope with the TJ Maxx gift card had been mailed by an undercover investigator from the district attorney's office — a decoy, planted to find out whether gift cards and lottery tickets were vanishing somewhere inside the Oakdale facility, according to information prosecutors released after her arrest. It worked almost immediately.
The very next day, Nov. 20, 2025, security cameras inside a TJ Maxx in Port Jefferson Station caught Jamison-Lewis at the register, using the stolen gift card to buy clothing, jewelry, a handbag and reusable shopping bags, the district attorney's office says.
The footage gave investigators something stronger than a tip: a face, a date, a register receipt, and a gift card number that traced straight back to an envelope they themselves had mailed days earlier.
Those two envelopes from Nov. 19 are the only theft prosecutors have laid out step by step in public filings. But they're also why everything after it — the arrest, the searches, the guilty plea — moved so fast.
A new hire, a federal watchdog, seven victims
Jamison-Lewis was 36, from Mastic Beach, and had only worked for the U.S. Postal Service since November 2024 — just over a year. She resigned on Dec. 1, 2025, roughly a week after investigators took her into custody.
Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney's office ran the investigation. They worked it alongside agents from the U.S. Postal Service Office of Inspector General — the federal watchdog that polices theft and fraud by postal employees.
Since her arrest, the DA's office says it has identified at least seven victims — people whose gift cards and lottery tickets were pulled out of the mail stream before they ever reached the people they were addressed to. None of them has been publicly named.
At a press conference on Dec. 12, 2025 announcing the charges, Tierney's office put the evidence on display: photos of the recovered mail, the stolen gift cards, and the merchandise Jamison-Lewis had bought with them.
Jamison-Lewis pleaded guilty before Acting Supreme Court Justice Richard I. Horowitz. Her attorney, Matthew Hereth, did not immediately respond to a request for comment, according to Patch.
"This defendant betrayed that trust for her own benefit, and her guilty plea makes clear that abusing a position of public trust comes with consequences," — Ray Tierney, Suffolk County District Attorney, per Patch
What the searches turned up next
Four days after that TJ Maxx shopping trip showed up on camera, investigators moved. On Nov. 24, 2025, agents from the Suffolk County DA's office and the USPS Office of Inspector General arrested Jamison-Lewis. She still had four more pieces of stolen mail in her pocketbook. Officers also recovered the clothing, jewelry and handbag she'd bought with the stolen gift card.
That wasn't the end of it. Investigators ran court-authorized search warrants at her home and her vehicle — and found 20 more pieces of mail they believe she'd also stolen. Among them: several more gift cards, worth a combined $800.
Add it up and investigators recovered 24 pieces of stolen mail total, between the arrest and the two searches — on top of the two envelopes she'd already emptied and resealed back on Nov. 19.
USPS OIG agents aren't a local add-on. They're the federal arm that polices theft by postal employees nationwide, which is a sign this case was never treated as a one-office problem.
Jamison-Lewis was indicted in August 2026, as the investigation grew from that one decoy envelope into the seven victims prosecutors say they ultimately identified.
Twenty counts, and what each one means
Nearly a year after her arrest, on Nov. 13, 2026, Jamison-Lewis stood before Acting Supreme Court Justice Richard I. Horowitz and pleaded guilty — to 20 counts tied to the scheme.
Eighteen of those counts are felonies. Nine counts of fourth-degree grand larceny, nine counts of fourth-degree criminal possession of stolen property — all Class E felonies, the lowest felony tier in New York's penal code. It's still a felony record, though, for someone who handled other people's property every single day on the job.
The other two counts are misdemeanors: one count of petit larceny, one count of fifth-degree criminal possession of stolen property, both Class A misdemeanors.
She's due back in court for sentencing on Jan. 11, 2027, in front of Justice Horowitz. No sentencing recommendation has been made public.
The trust she broke, in Tierney's own words
Tierney framed the entire case around one idea: the trust a postal clerk is handed every single day. "People trust the postal service to deliver their mail safely and securely, not to have envelopes picked through and contents stolen," he said, according to Patch.
After the guilty plea, Tierney's office went back to that same idea, sharper this time. "This defendant betrayed that trust for her own benefit, and her guilty plea makes clear that abusing a position of public trust comes with consequences," Tierney said, per Patch.
Jamison-Lewis's attorney, Matthew Hereth, hadn't responded to a request for comment by the time Patch published its report on the guilty plea.
What the numbers actually add up to
Strip away the shopping spree, and the case comes down to numbers prosecutors can actually prove. A $175 gift card and three scratch-off tickets, taken from one envelope. Another $800 in gift cards, found in her home and car. And at least seven victims whose mail never reached where it was addressed.
Prosecutors haven't put a total dollar figure on the scheme beyond those individual amounts. And they haven't said how long the thefts were going on before that Nov. 19, 2025 decoy envelope finally caught her.
What the record does show is a pattern. Mail taken, opened, emptied, resealed to look untouched — then dropped back into the outgoing bin like nothing had happened. Investigators say that same method repeated across multiple pieces of mail before she was caught.
What happens next
Jamison-Lewis is due back in court on Jan. 11, 2027, for sentencing before Acting Supreme Court Justice Richard I. Horowitz. Prosecutors haven't said what sentence they'll seek. Her attorney, Matthew Hereth, hadn't commented on the plea as of the most recent reporting.
How this plays in court
Prosecutors built this case on three legs. An undercover decoy envelope, surveillance footage from a TJ Maxx register, and the physical recovery of 24 additional stolen items from her home, car and pocketbook. That combination of controlled evidence and corroborating recovery typically pushes a case toward a plea rather than a trial.
The guilty plea to 20 counts, including 18 Class E felonies, locks in the factual record for sentencing. Prosecutors will likely point to the position of trust a postal clerk holds. They'll also point to the number of identified victims — at least seven — to argue for a sentence above the statutory minimum.
Class E felonies carry New York's lowest felony sentencing range. In comparable postal-theft cases, defense attorneys often argue for probation when a defendant has no prior record. That argument gets stronger when the defendant has already resigned from the position of trust and pleaded guilty rather than forcing a trial.
Justice Horowitz will weigh what was recovered against the scope of the scheme. On one side: a $175 gift card, $800 in additional cards, and the merchandise bought at TJ Maxx. On the other: seven known victims and 24 pieces of stolen mail recovered after the arrest. Both sides will shape the choice between probation and jail time.
- NY Post: Long Island Postal Worker Caught On Camera Shopping Spree With Your Stolen Gift Card
- Yahoo: Long Island postal worker admits to stealing lotto tickets, gifts from mail: DA
- Greater Long Island: Former Oakdale postal clerk pleads guilty to stealing from outgoing mail
- Long Island Life & Politics: Ex-USPS Worker Pleads Guilty to Stealing Mail from Post Office
- Patch: Oakdale Postal Worker Pleads Guilty To Stealing Gift Cards, Lottery Tickets: DA