CHARGED

Man Who Renamed Himself Captain America Charged With Killing Elderly Illinois Man, Hijacking Car

· How we report

A man who legally renamed himself after a Marvel superhero is accused of beating a 63-year-old Peoria man to death, then handing the victim's girlfriend a note demanding "all of her money" while she drove him home.

Case at a glance

  • Captain Cautious America — Murder suspect, formerly Mark Anderson, charged
  • Khanh Dinh — Victim, 63, Peoria, Illinois, victim

Next: America remains held without bond at the Tazewell County Jail. No court date has been reported yet for either the first-degree murder charge in Peoria County or the aggravated vehicle hijacking, armed robbery and aggravated unlawful restraint charges in Tazewell County. It is also still unclear whether he has retained defense counsel.

Man Who Renamed Himself Captain America Charged With Killing Elderly Illinois Man, Hijacking Car

A favor turns into a robbery

She was just giving her boyfriend's coworker a ride home. That's how Friday, Nov. 13 started for a woman in the Peoria area. The coworker was a 34-year-old man who had legally changed his name years earlier to Captain Cautious America.

Somewhere in that car, he told her something no passenger should ever say. Her boyfriend — 63-year-old Khanh Dinh — was dead, America said, according to the Peoria County State's Attorney's Office. Then he handed her a note.

Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
Vinnie Uncensored: one free email every Sunday.

It demanded "all of her money," the State's Attorney's Office said in a statement released Monday, Nov. 16. She didn't stick around to find out what came next. She got out of the car and called 911.

Tazewell County police took the call. They went looking for the man she described, and they found him fast — he was in custody by Saturday, Nov. 14, less than a day after she'd agreed to drive him home.

A welfare check ends in a body

Officers pulled America out of the patrol car, and that's when they found the note, according to WCBU. What it said — and what the woman said he'd told her — pointed them straight to an address.

Peoria Police drove to the 2700 block of North Sheridan Road to check on Dinh. They found him dead inside his own home.

A preliminary autopsy says blunt-force head trauma killed him, prosecutors said. Illinois State Police and Peoria Police both responded, according to local reporting cited by the New York Post.

"all of her money" — Peoria County State's Attorney's Office, describing the demand in the note

The coworker, the superhero, and the ballot

Khanh Dinh was 63 and lived alone on North Sheridan Road, in the house where he died. The coverage identifies him only by his age, his address, and his role in the woman's life — her boyfriend.

The man charged with killing him was born Mark Anderson. Somewhere along the way, he decided a ballot needed a name people wouldn't forget. He legally became Captain Cautious America roughly a decade ago, according to AOL/People, or in 2018, according to the New York Post — the outlets disagree on the year, but they agree on the reason: he wanted to run for office, a detail first reported at the time by the Peoria Journal Star.

He and Dinh knew each other through work. The State's Attorney's Office has described him as Dinh's coworker — the connection that put him in the girlfriend's car that Friday.

Four charges, two counties

In Peoria County, America faces first-degree murder in Dinh's death. It's the most serious charge Illinois prosecutors can bring short of a capital case, and it covers the killing itself.

In Tazewell County, where he was arrested, three more charges stack on top: aggravated vehicle hijacking, armed robbery, and aggravated unlawful restraint. Each one tracks a piece of what happened in that car — taking it over, demanding money by note, and keeping the woman from leaving before she managed to get out on her own.

The Peoria County State's Attorney's Office confirmed the full charging picture as of Monday, Nov. 16. America is sitting in the Tazewell County Jail without bond, according to online court records cited by AOL/People.

What the record actually says

The note and the demand come straight from prosecutors' own account. "All of her money" — that's the exact phrase the Peoria County State's Attorney's Office used to describe the demand, as reported by AOL/People.

WCBU reported that investigators pulled the suspected note off America right after officers took him out of the patrol car. It's physical evidence that lines up with what the girlfriend says happened in the vehicle.

Go back further, and the Peoria Journal Star's old reporting on the name change now explains the strangest detail in the story. Both the New York Post and AOL/People are citing it to answer the obvious question: why does a murder suspect have a superhero's name? He wanted to stand out on a ballot.

As of this reporting, it's unclear whether America has an attorney who can speak for him, according to AOL/People. No statement from the defense has surfaced.

What happens next

America remains held without bond at the Tazewell County Jail. No court date has been reported yet for either the first-degree murder charge in Peoria County or the aggravated vehicle hijacking, armed robbery and aggravated unlawful restraint charges in Tazewell County. It is also still unclear whether he has retained defense counsel.

The legal read

How this plays in court

A first-degree murder case built partly on blunt-force trauma findings will lean heavily on the forensic autopsy and any physical evidence recovered from Dinh's home — the preliminary cause of death will need to be confirmed and tied to a timeline that places America at the scene.

The robbery and hijacking charges rest largely on the girlfriend's account and the recovered note; prosecutors will want to establish the note's authorship conclusively, likely through handwriting analysis or an admission, since the note is the clearest physical link between the car and the alleged crime.

The defense is likely to probe the sequence prosecutors are offering — how America knew Dinh was dead before police did, and whether that knowledge points to involvement or could be explained another way — since that claim, made to the girlfriend before any welfare check, is central to the state's theory.

A jury weighing the aggravated unlawful restraint count will look closely at how the girlfriend got out of the vehicle: whether she was physically prevented from leaving or chose the moment herself, since that distinction matters to whether restraint, as opposed to simple presence in the car, can be proven.

Sources. This report draws on the following coverage; quotes are reproduced as those outlets printed them.
  • NY Post: Man Who Renamed Himself Captain America Charged With Killing Elderly Illinois Man, Hijacking Car
  • AOL.com: Man Legally Named Captain America Charged with Murder After Allegedly Handing Victim’s Girlfriend Chilling Note
Vinnie Politan is a former prosecutor and veteran trial anchor.
Vinnie Uncensored · every Sunday
Get the uncensored details I'm not allowed to cover on Facebook.
One email every Sunday: the week's biggest cases, the real charges, nothing softened. Free. Unsubscribe anytime.